FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   811   812   813   814   815   816   817   818   819   820   821   822   823   824   825   826   827   828   829   830   831   832   833   834   835  
836   837   838   839   840   841   842   843   844   845   846   847   848   849   850   851   852   853   854   855   856   857   858   859   860   >>   >|  
wer that,_ "Synderesis" is not a power but a habit; though some held that it is a power higher than reason; while others [*Cf. Alexander of Hales, Sum. Theol. II, Q. 73] said that it is reason itself, not as reason, but as a nature. In order to make this clear we must observe that, as we have said above (A. 8), man's act of reasoning, since it is a kind of movement, proceeds from the understanding of certain things--namely, those which are naturally known without any investigation on the part of reason, as from an immovable principle--and ends also at the understanding, inasmuch as by means of those principles naturally known, we judge of those things which we have discovered by reasoning. Now it is clear that, as the speculative reason argues about speculative things, so that practical reason argues about practical things. Therefore we must have, bestowed on us by nature, not only speculative principles, but also practical principles. Now the first speculative principles bestowed on us by nature do not belong to a special power, but to a special habit, which is called "the understanding of principles," as the Philosopher explains (Ethic. vi, 6). Wherefore the first practical principles, bestowed on us by nature, do not belong to a special power, but to a special natural habit, which we call "synderesis." Whence "synderesis" is said to incite to good, and to murmur at evil, inasmuch as through first principles we proceed to discover, and judge of what we have discovered. It is therefore clear that "synderesis" is not a power, but a natural habit. Reply Obj. 1: The division given by Jerome is taken from the variety of acts, and not from the variety of powers; and various acts can belong to one power. Reply Obj. 2: In like manner, the opposition of sensuality to "syneresis" is an opposition of acts, and not of the different species of one genus. Reply Obj. 3: Those unchangeable notions are the first practical principles, concerning which no one errs; and they are attributed to reason as to a power, and to "synderesis" as to a habit. Wherefore we judge naturally both by our reason and by "synderesis." _______________________ THIRTEENTH ARTICLE [I, Q. 79, Art. 13] Whether Conscience Be a Power? Objection 1: It would seem that conscience is a power; for Origen says [*Commentary on Rom. 2:15] that "conscience is a correcting and guiding spirit accompanying the soul, by which it is led away from evil and made to
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   811   812   813   814   815   816   817   818   819   820   821   822   823   824   825   826   827   828   829   830   831   832   833   834   835  
836   837   838   839   840   841   842   843   844   845   846   847   848   849   850   851   852   853   854   855   856   857   858   859   860   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

principles

 

reason

 
synderesis
 

practical

 

things

 

nature

 

special

 
speculative
 

bestowed

 

understanding


belong

 

naturally

 

discovered

 

argues

 
opposition
 

Wherefore

 

conscience

 

variety

 

natural

 

reasoning


Jerome

 

sensuality

 
division
 
powers
 
syneresis
 

manner

 
Origen
 

Commentary

 
Objection
 
accompanying

correcting
 

guiding

 
spirit
 
Conscience
 

notions

 

unchangeable

 
attributed
 
Whether
 

THIRTEENTH

 
ARTICLE

species

 

Therefore

 

observe

 

higher

 

Synderesis

 

Alexander

 
movement
 

proceeds

 
Whence
 

explains