FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   809   810   811   812   813   814   815   816   817   818   819   820   821   822   823   824   825   826   827   828   829   830   831   832   833  
834   835   836   837   838   839   840   841   842   843   844   845   846   847   848   849   850   851   852   853   854   855   856   857   858   >>   >|  
he powers vary, but only what cannot be reduced to the one same principle, as we have said above (Q. 78, A. 4). _______________________ ELEVENTH ARTICLE [I, Q. 79, Art. 11] Whether the Speculative and Practical Intellects Are Distinct Powers? Objection 1: It would seem that the speculative and practical intellects are distinct powers. For the apprehensive and motive are different kinds of powers, as is clear from _De Anima_ ii, 3. But the speculative intellect is merely an apprehensive power; while the practical intellect is a motive power. Therefore they are distinct powers. Obj. 2: Further, the different nature of the object differentiates the power. But the object of the speculative intellect is _truth,_ and of the practical is _good;_ which differ in nature. Therefore the speculative and practical intellect are distinct powers. Obj. 3: Further, in the intellectual part, the practical intellect is compared to the speculative, as the estimative is to the imaginative power in the sensitive part. But the estimative differs from the imaginative, as power form power, as we have said above (Q. 78, A. 4). Therefore also the speculative intellect differs from the practical. _On the contrary,_ The speculative intellect by extension becomes practical (De Anima iii, 10). But one power is not changed into another. Therefore the speculative and practical intellects are not distinct powers. _I answer that,_ The speculative and practical intellects are not distinct powers. The reason of which is that, as we have said above (Q. 77, A. 3), what is accidental to the nature of the object of a power, does not differentiate that power; for it is accidental to a thing colored to be man, or to be great or small; hence all such things are apprehended by the same power of sight. Now, to a thing apprehended by the intellect, it is accidental whether it be directed to operation or not, and according to this the speculative and practical intellects differ. For it is the speculative intellect which directs what it apprehends, not to operation, but to the consideration of truth; while the practical intellect is that which directs what it apprehends to operation. And this is what the Philosopher says (De Anima iii, 10); that "the speculative differs from the practical in its end." Whence each is named from its end: the one speculative, the other practical--i.e. operative. Reply Obj. 1: The practical intellect is a motive power,
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   809   810   811   812   813   814   815   816   817   818   819   820   821   822   823   824   825   826   827   828   829   830   831   832   833  
834   835   836   837   838   839   840   841   842   843   844   845   846   847   848   849   850   851   852   853   854   855   856   857   858   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

practical

 

speculative

 
intellect
 

powers

 

distinct

 

intellects

 

Therefore

 
motive
 

nature


accidental

 

operation

 

differs

 

object

 

estimative

 
differ
 

Further

 

directs

 

apprehended


imaginative

 

apprehensive

 

apprehends

 

differentiate

 
colored
 
Whence
 
operative
 

Philosopher

 
reason

things

 
directed
 
consideration
 
Whether
 

ELEVENTH

 
ARTICLE
 
Speculative
 

Practical

 

Objection


Powers
 
Intellects
 

Distinct

 
extension
 

reduced

 

contrary

 

changed

 

sensitive

 

differentiates


compared

 
intellectual
 

principle

 
answer