FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   704   705   706   707   708   709   710   711   712   713   714   715   716   717   718   719   720   721   722   723   724   725   726   727   728  
729   730   731   732   733   734   735   736   737   738   739   740   741   742   743   744   745   746   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   >>   >|  
in any cause. Jurisdiction is the power to declare the law and when it ceases to exist, the only function remaining to the Court is that of announcing the fact and dismissing the cause."[595] Although the McCardle Case goes to the ultimate in sustaining Congressional power over the court's appellate jurisdiction and although it was born of the stresses and tensions of the Reconstruction period, it has been frequently reaffirmed and approved.[596] The result is to vest an unrestrained discretion in Congress to curtail and even abolish the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, and to prescribe the manner and forms in which it may be exercised. This principle is well expressed in The "Francis Wright"[597] where the Court sustained the validity of an act of Congress which limited the court's review in admiralty cases to questions of law appearing on the record. A portion of the opinion is worthy of quotation: "Authority to limit the jurisdiction necessarily carries with it authority to limit the use of the jurisdiction. Not only may whole classes of cases be kept out of the jurisdiction altogether, but particular classes of questions may be subjected to reexamination and review, while others are not. To our minds it is no more unconstitutional to provide that issues of fact shall not be retried in any case, than that neither issues of law nor fact shall be retried in cases where the value of the matter in dispute is less than $5,000. The general power to regulate implies the power to regulate in all things. The whole of a civil appeal may be given, or a part. The constitutional requirements are all satisfied if one opportunity is had for the trial of all parts of a case. Everything beyond that is a matter of legislative discretion."[598] The Power of Congress To Regulate the Jurisdiction of the Lower Federal Courts MARTIN _v._ HUNTER'S LESSEE The power of Congress to vest, withdraw, and regulate the jurisdiction of the lower federal courts is derived from the power to create tribunals under article I, the necessary and proper clause, and the clause in article III, vesting the judicial power in the Supreme Court and such inferior courts as "the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish." Balancing these provisions, however, are the phrases in article III to the effect that the judicial power "shall be vested" in courts and "shall extend" to nine classes of cases and controversies and the questi
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   704   705   706   707   708   709   710   711   712   713   714   715   716   717   718   719   720   721   722   723   724   725   726   727   728  
729   730   731   732   733   734   735   736   737   738   739   740   741   742   743   744   745   746   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

jurisdiction

 

Congress

 

article

 

courts

 

regulate

 
classes
 

clause

 

review

 
Supreme
 
questions

issues

 
discretion
 
judicial
 
matter
 

retried

 

Jurisdiction

 
appellate
 

satisfied

 

general

 

requirements


implies

 
things
 

opportunity

 

appeal

 

dispute

 

constitutional

 

withdraw

 
ordain
 

establish

 

Balancing


inferior

 
proper
 

vesting

 
provisions
 
controversies
 
questi
 

extend

 

vested

 

phrases

 

effect


Regulate

 
Federal
 

Courts

 

Everything

 

legislative

 

MARTIN

 

derived

 

create

 

tribunals

 

federal