FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   384   385   386   387   388   389   390   391   392   393   394   395   396   397   398   399   400   401   402   403   404   405   406   407   408  
409   410   411   412   413   414   415   416   417   418   419   420   421   422   423   424   425   426   427   428   429   430   431   432   433   >>   >|  
States, or to diminish their autonomy in its employment, would be, in fact to remove their reason for being, and so the reason for the Federal System itself. So while the power of Congress to regulate commerce among the States and with foreign nations is in terms a single power, in the intention of the framers it comprised two very different powers. In the field of foreign relations, the National Government is completely sovereign, and the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations is but a branch of this sovereign power. The power to regulate commerce among the States is, on the other hand, not a sovereign power except for purposes of commercial advantage; in other respects it is confronted at every turn by the police power of the States, and hence requires to be defined in relation to the known and frequently reiterated objectives of that power. Indeed, it was urged on the authority of Madison that the power to regulate commerce among the States was not bestowed upon the National Government "to be used for * * * positive purposes," but merely as "a negative and preventive provision against injustice among the States themselves." Madison IV, Letters and Other Writings, 15 (Philadelphia, 1865). Furthermore, it is a power which was designed for the _promotion_ and _advancement_ of commerce, not a power to strike commerce down in order to advance other purposes and programs. Grant that the power to regulate commerce among the States is the power to prohibit it at the discretion of Congress, and you at once endow Congress with power which it may use as a weapon to consolidate substantially all power in the hands of the National Government. Thus, if Congress may prohibit _ad libitum_ the carrying on of interstate commerce, it may make deprivation of the right to engage in interstate commerce in any of its phases, even the right to move from one State to another, a sanction of ever-increasing efficacy for whatever standards of conduct it may choose to lay down in any field of human action; and since laws passed by Congress in pursuance of its powers are generally supreme over conflicting State laws, these standards would supersede the conflicting standards imposed under the police powers of the States. Henceforth, in effect, the police power would exist solely by "leave and license" of Congress--as "the power to govern men and things" it would be at an end; and by the same token the Federal System, which is the ou
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   384   385   386   387   388   389   390   391   392   393   394   395   396   397   398   399   400   401   402   403   404   405   406   407   408  
409   410   411   412   413   414   415   416   417   418   419   420   421   422   423   424   425   426   427   428   429   430   431   432   433   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

commerce

 

States

 
Congress
 

regulate

 

standards

 

police

 
Government
 
purposes
 

National

 

sovereign


powers
 
foreign
 
System
 

Federal

 

interstate

 

conflicting

 
reason
 

nations

 

Madison

 

prohibit


deprivation

 

engage

 

phases

 

diminish

 

weapon

 

discretion

 

consolidate

 

substantially

 

libitum

 

sanction


carrying

 

solely

 

effect

 

Henceforth

 

imposed

 
license
 
govern
 

things

 

supersede

 

conduct


choose
 
increasing
 

efficacy

 

action

 

generally

 

supreme

 
pursuance
 

passed

 
promotion
 

commercial