FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   367   368   369   370   371   372   373   374   375   376   377   378   379   380   381   382   383   384   385   386   387   388   389   390   391  
>>  
7b} See _Calendar of State Papers_, Domestic, 1595-7, p. 310. {368a} See Warners _Catalogue of Dulwich MSS._ pp. 24-6. {368b} Cf. _ibid._ pp. 26-7. {369a} See p. 235, note I. {369b} Cf. Warner's _Dulwich MSS._ pp.30-31. {369c} See p. 254, note I. {370} Most of those that are commonly quoted are phrases in ordinary use by all writers of the day. The only point of any interest raised in the argument from parallelisms of expression centres about a quotation from Aristotle which Bacon and Shakespeare not merely both make, but make in what looks at a first glance to be the same erroneous form. Aristotle wrote in his _Nicomachean Ethics_, i. 8, that young men were unfitted for the study of _political_ philosophy. Bacon, in the _Advancement of Learning_ (1605), wrote: 'Is not the opinion of Aristotle worthy to be regarded wherein he saith that young men are not fit auditors of _moral_ philosophy?' (bk. ii. p. 255, ed. Kitchin). Shakespeare, about 1603, in _Troilus and Cressida_, II. ii. 166, wrote of 'young men whom Aristotle thought unfit to hear _moral_ philosophy.' But the alleged error of substituting _moral_ for _political_ philosophy in Aristotle's text is more apparent than real. By 'political' philosophy Aristotle, as his context amply shows, meant the ethics of civil society, which are hardly distinguishable from what is commonly called 'morals.' In the summary paraphrase of Aristotle's _Ethics_ which was translated into English from the Italian, and published in 1547, the passage to which both Shakespeare and Bacon refer is not rendered literally, but its general drift is given as a warning that moral philosophy is not a fit subject for study by youths who are naturally passionate and headstrong. Such an interpretation of Aristotle's language is common among sixteenth and seventeenth century writers. Erasmus, in the epistle at the close of his popular _Colloquia_ (Florence, 1530, sig. Q Q), wrote of his endeavour to insinuate serious precepts 'into the minds of young men whom Aristotle rightly described as unfit auditors of moral philosophy' ('in animos adolescentium, quos recte scripsit Aristoteles inidoneos auditores ethicae philosophiae'). In a French translation of the _Ethics_ by the Comte de Plessis, published at Paris in 1553, the passage is rendered 'parquoy le ieune enfant n'est suffisant auditeur de la science civile;' and an English commentator (in a manuscript note written abou
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   367   368   369   370   371   372   373   374   375   376   377   378   379   380   381   382   383   384   385   386   387   388   389   390   391  
>>  



Top keywords:

Aristotle

 

philosophy

 

political

 
Ethics
 

Shakespeare

 
rendered
 

passage

 
Dulwich
 

published

 
auditors

English

 
commonly
 
writers
 
commentator
 

civile

 
science
 

youths

 

passionate

 

warning

 
naturally

headstrong

 

subject

 
called
 

morals

 

written

 

summary

 

distinguishable

 

ethics

 

society

 

paraphrase


interpretation

 

general

 

manuscript

 
literally
 

translated

 

Italian

 
animos
 

adolescentium

 
rightly
 

insinuate


precepts

 
philosophiae
 

French

 
translation
 

ethicae

 

auditores

 
scripsit
 

Aristoteles

 

Plessis

 

inidoneos