FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1129   1130   1131   1132   1133   1134   1135   1136   1137   1138   1139   1140   1141   1142   1143   1144   1145   1146   1147   1148   1149   1150   1151   1152   1153  
1154   1155   1156   1157   1158   1159   1160   1161   1162   1163   1164   1165   >>  
a man intending to dig a grave finds a treasure. Now it is manifest that a acts after the manner of a natural principle: wherefore its effects in this world are natural. It is therefore impossible that any active power of a heavenly body be the cause of what happens by accident here below, whether by luck or by chance. We must therefore say that what happens here by accident, both in natural things and in human affairs, is reduced to a preordaining cause, which is Divine Providence. For nothing hinders that which happens by accident being considered as one by an intellect: otherwise the intellect could not form this proposition: "The digger of a grave found a treasure." And just as an intellect can apprehend this so can it effect it; for instance, someone who knows a place where a treasure is hidden, might instigate a rustic, ignorant of this, to dig a grave there. Consequently, nothing hinders what happens here by accident, by luck or by chance, being reduced to some ordering cause which acts by the intellect, especially the Divine intellect. For God alone can change the will, as shown above (Q. 105, A. 4). Consequently the ordering of human actions, the principle of which is the will, must be ascribed to God alone. So therefore inasmuch as all that happens here below is subject to Divine Providence, as being pre-ordained, and as it were "fore-spoken," we can admit the existence of fate: although the holy doctors avoided the use of this word, on account of those who twisted its application to a certain force in the position of the stars. Hence Augustine says (De Civ. Dei v, 1): "If anyone ascribes human affairs to fate, meaning thereby the will or power of God, let him keep to his opinion, but hold his tongue." For this reason Gregory denies the existence of fate: wherefore the first objection's solution is manifest. Reply Obj. 2: Nothing hinders certain things happening by luck or by chance, if compared to their proximate causes: but not if compared to Divine Providence, whereby "nothing happens at random in the world," as Augustine says (QQ. 83, qu. 24). _______________________ SECOND ARTICLE [I, Q. 116, Art. 2] Whether Fate Is in Created Things? Objection 1: It would seem that fate is not in created things. For Augustine says (De Civ. Dei v, 1) that the "Divine will or power is called fate." But the Divine will or power is not in creatures, but in God. Therefore fate is not in creatures but in God.
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1129   1130   1131   1132   1133   1134   1135   1136   1137   1138   1139   1140   1141   1142   1143   1144   1145   1146   1147   1148   1149   1150   1151   1152   1153  
1154   1155   1156   1157   1158   1159   1160   1161   1162   1163   1164   1165   >>  



Top keywords:
Divine
 
intellect
 
accident
 

chance

 
Providence
 

treasure

 
things
 
Augustine
 

hinders

 

natural


ordering

 
Consequently
 

compared

 

reduced

 

manifest

 
creatures
 

affairs

 

principle

 

existence

 

wherefore


opinion

 

tongue

 

reason

 

account

 

position

 

Gregory

 

application

 

meaning

 
ascribes
 
twisted

Whether

 
SECOND
 

ARTICLE

 

Created

 

Things

 

called

 

Therefore

 

created

 

Objection

 

Nothing


solution

 
objection
 

happening

 

random

 

proximate

 
denies
 
digger
 

proposition

 

apprehend

 
instance