there is an antecedent of
_who_ or _which_, and whether _what_ = _that_ + _which_ (if so, it is
a simple relative; if not, it is either an indefinite relative or an
interrogative pronoun); (2) see if the pronoun introduces an indirect
question (if it does, it is an interrogative; if not, it is an
indefinite relative).
[Sidenote: _Another caution._]
128. On the other hand, care must be taken to see whether the
pronoun is the word that really _asks the question_ in an
interrogative sentence. Examine the following:--
1. Sweet rose! whence is this hue
_Which_ doth all hues excel?
--DRUMMOND
2. And then what wonders shall you do
_Whose_ dawning beauty warms us so?
--WALKER
3. Is this a romance? Or is it a faithful picture of _what_ has
lately been in a neighboring land?--MACAULAY
These are interrogative sentences, but in none of them does the
pronoun ask the question. In the first, _whence_ is the interrogative
word, _which_ has the antecedent _hue_. In the second, _whose_ has the
antecedent _you_, and asks no question. In the third, the question is
asked by the verb.
OMISSION OF THE RELATIVES.
[Sidenote: _Relative omitted when_ object.]
129. The relative is frequently omitted in spoken and in literary
English when it would be the object of a preposition or a verb. Hardly
a writer can be found who does not leave out relatives in this way
when they can be readily supplied in the mind of the reader. Thus,--
These are the sounds we feed upon.--FLETCHER.
I visited many other apartments, but shall not trouble my reader
with all the curiosities I observed.--SWIFT.
Exercise.
Put in the relatives _who_, _which_, or _that_ where they are omitted
from the following sentences, and see whether the sentences are any
smoother or clearer:--
1. The insect I am now describing lived three years,--GOLDSMITH.
2. They will go to Sunday schools through storms their brothers
are afraid of.--HOLMES.
3. He opened the volume he first took from the shelf.--G. ELIOT.
4. He could give the coals in that queer coal scuttle we read of
to his poor neighbor.--THACKERAY.
5. When Goldsmith died, half the unpaid bill he owed to Mr.
William Filby was for clothes supplied to his nephew.--FORSTER
6. The thing I want to see is not Redbook Lists, and Court
Calendars, but the life of man in England.--CARLYLE.
7. Th
|