FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1395   1396   1397   1398   1399   1400   1401   1402   1403   1404   1405   1406   1407   1408   1409   1410   1411   1412   1413   1414   1415   1416   1417   1418   1419  
1420   1421   1422   1423   1424   1425   1426   1427   1428   1429   1430   1431   1432   1433   1434   1435   1436   1437   1438   1439   1440   1441   1442   1443   1444   >>   >|  
hem and the pronouns, as it is between the preceding verbs and the pronouns _him_ and _her_. But, in fact, "You have given him more than _I_," is perfectly good English; the last clause of which plainly means--"more than I _have given him_." And, "You have sent her as much as _he_," will of course be understood to mean--"as much as he _has sent her_;" but here, because the auxiliary implied is different from the one expressed, it might have been as well to have inserted it: thus, "_You have_ sent her as much as _he has_." "She reviles you as much as _he_," is also good English, though found, with the foregoing, among Buchanan's examples of "false syntax." OBS. 20.--Murray's twentieth Rule of syntax avers, that, "When the qualities of different things are compared, the latter noun or pronoun is _not governed_ by the conjunction _than_ or _as_, but agrees with the verb," &c.--_Octavo Gram._, p. 214; _Russell's Gram._, 103; _Bacon's_, 51; _Alger's_, 71; _Smith's_, 179; _Fisk's_, 138. To this rule, the great Compiler and most of his followers say, that _than whom_ "is an exception." or "_seems to form_ an exception;" to which they add, that, "the phrase is, however, avoided by the best modern writers."--_Murray_, i, 215. This latter assertion Russell conceives to be untrue: the former he adopts; and, calling _than whom_ "an exception to the general rule," says of it, (with no great consistency,) "Here the conjunction _than_ has certainly the force of a preposition, and supplies its place by governing the relative."--_Russell's Abridgement of Murray's Gram._, p. 104. But this is hardly an instance to which one would apply the maxim elsewhere adopted by Murray: "_Exceptio probat regulam_."--_Octavo Gram._, p. 205. To ascribe to a conjunction the governing power of a preposition, is a very wide step, and quite too much like straddling the line which separates these parts of speech one from the other. OBS. 21.--Churchill says, "If there be no ellipsis to supply, as sometimes happens when a pronoun relative occurs after _than_; the relative is to be put in the _objective case absolute_: as, 'Alfred, _than whom_ a greater king never reigned, deserves to be held up as a model to all future sovereigns.'"--_New Gram._, p. 153. Among his Notes, he has one with reference to this "_objective case absolute_," as follows: "It is not governed by the conjunction, for on no other occasion does a conjunction govern any case; or by any word
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1395   1396   1397   1398   1399   1400   1401   1402   1403   1404   1405   1406   1407   1408   1409   1410   1411   1412   1413   1414   1415   1416   1417   1418   1419  
1420   1421   1422   1423   1424   1425   1426   1427   1428   1429   1430   1431   1432   1433   1434   1435   1436   1437   1438   1439   1440   1441   1442   1443   1444   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

conjunction

 

Murray

 
relative
 

exception

 

Russell

 

governed

 

pronoun

 

syntax

 

objective

 

absolute


governing
 

preposition

 
Octavo
 

English

 

pronouns

 

ascribe

 

speech

 

separates

 

straddling

 

Exceptio


Abridgement
 

supplies

 

instance

 

adopted

 

probat

 

regulam

 

sovereigns

 

future

 
reference
 
govern

occasion

 
deserves
 

supply

 

ellipsis

 

Churchill

 
occurs
 
reigned
 

greater

 
Alfred
 
preceding

calling

 
implied
 
auxiliary
 

compared

 
qualities
 
things
 

understood

 

agrees

 
inserted
 

foregoing