FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   744   745   746   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   754   755   756   757   758   759   760   761   762   763   764   765   766   767   768  
769   770   771   772   773   774   775   776   777   778   779   780   781   782   783   784   785   786   787   788   789   790   791   792   793   >>   >|  
explain each other, is sufficiently shown above; and thereby is refuted Sanborn's chief argument, that, "_is being burned_," involves the contradiction of "_existing, burned_," or "_consumed by fire_." According to his reasoning, as well as that of Bullions, _is burned_ must mean _exists consumed; was burned, existed consumed_; and thus our whole passive conjugation would often be found made up of bald absurdities! That this new _unco-passive_ form conflicts with the older and better usage of taking the progressive form sometimes passively, is doubtless a good argument against the innovation; but that "Johnson and Addison" are fit representatives of the older "practice" in this case, may be doubted. I know not that the latter has anywhere made use of such phraseology; and one or two examples from the former are scarcely an offset to his positive verdict against the usage. See OBS. 3rd, above. OBS. 10.--As to what is called "_the present_ or _the imperfect participle passive_,"--as, "_being burned_," or "_being burnt_,"--if it is rightly interpreted in _any_ of the foregoing citations, it is, beyond question, very improperly _thus_ named. In participles, _ing_ denotes _continuance_: thus _being_ usually means _continuing to be; loving, continuing to love; building, continuing to build_,--or (as taken passively) _continuing to be built_: i. e., (in words which express the sense more precisely and certainly,) _continuing to be in process of construction_. What then is "being built," but "_continuing to be built_," the same, or nearly the same, as "_building_" taken passively? True it is, that _built_, when alone, being a perfect participle, does not mean "_in process of construction_," but rather, "_constructed_" which intimates _completion_; yet, in the foregoing passive phrases, and others like them, as well as in all examples of this unco-passive voice, continuance of the passive state being first suggested, and cessation of the act being either regarded as future or disregarded, the imperfect participle passive is for the most part received as equivalent to the simple imperfect used in a passive sense. But Dr. Bullions, who, after making "_is being built_ precisely equivalent to _is built_," classes the two participles differently, and both erroneously,--the one as a "_present_ participle," and the other, of late, as a "_past_,"--has also said above, "'_Built_,' is a _perfect_ participle: and THEREFORE cannot, in _any
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   744   745   746   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   754   755   756   757   758   759   760   761   762   763   764   765   766   767   768  
769   770   771   772   773   774   775   776   777   778   779   780   781   782   783   784   785   786   787   788   789   790   791   792   793   >>   >|  



Top keywords:
passive
 

continuing

 

participle

 
burned
 
consumed
 

imperfect

 
passively
 

precisely

 
construction
 

examples


perfect

 

process

 

argument

 

Bullions

 

foregoing

 

participles

 
continuance
 

building

 

present

 

equivalent


denotes

 
express
 

loving

 

making

 

received

 
simple
 

classes

 

differently

 

THEREFORE

 

erroneously


phrases

 

completion

 

constructed

 

intimates

 

regarded

 
future
 
disregarded
 

cessation

 

suggested

 

positive


conjugation

 

existed

 

absurdities

 
taking
 

progressive

 
conflicts
 

exists

 

refuted

 

Sanborn

 

explain