h other_ are
elliptical, for _Eteocles and Polynices killed--each the other_. Here the
second proposition expands and explains the first, whilst the first
supplies the verb to the second. Each, however, is elliptic.
s. 462. This is the syntax. As to the power of the words _each_ and _one_
in the expression (_each other_ and _one another_), I am not prepared to
say that in the common practice of the English language there is any
distinction between them. A distinction, however, if it existed, would give
strength to our language. Where two persons performed a reciprocal action
on another, the expression might be _one another_; as _Eteocles and
Polynices killed one another_. Where more than two persons were engaged on
each side of a reciprocal action, the expression might be _each other_; as,
_the ten champions praised each other_.
This amount of perspicuity is attained, by different processes, in the
French, Spanish, and Scandinavian languages.
1. French.--_Ils_ (i.e., A. and B.) _se battaient--l'un l'autre._ _Ils_ (A.
B. C.) _se battaient--les uns les autres._ In Spanish, _uno otro_ = _l'un
l'autre_, and _unos otros_ = _les uns les autres_.
2. Danish.--_Hin_ander = the French _l'un l'autre_; whilst _hverandre_ =
_les uns les autres_.
* * * * *
CHAPTER XII.
THE INDETERMINATE PRONOUNS.
s. 463. Different nations have different methods of expressing
indeterminate propositions.
Sometimes it is by the use of the passive voice. This is the common method
in Latin and Greek, and is also current in English--_dicitur_, [Greek:
legetai], _it is said_.
Sometimes the verb is reflective--_si dice_ = _it says itself_, Italian.
Sometimes the plural pronoun of the third person is used. This also is an
English locution--_they say_ = _the world at large says_.
Finally, the use of some word = _man_ is a common indeterminate expression.
The word _man_ has an indeterminate sense in the Modern German; as _man
sagt_ = _they say_.
The word _man_ was also used indeterminately in the Old English, although
it is not so used in the Modern.
In the Old English, the form _man_ often lost the -n, and became
_me_.--"Deutsche Grammatik." This form is also extinct.
s. 464. The present indeterminate pronoun is _one_; as _one says_ = _they
say_ = _it is said_ = _man sagt_, German = _on dit_, French = _si dice_,
Italian.
It has been stated, that the indeterminate pronoun _one_ has no
etymo
|