FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   648   649   650   651   652   653   654   655   656   657   658   659   660   661   662   663   664   665   666   667   668   669   670   671   672  
673   674   675   676   677   678   679   680   681   682   683   684   685   686   687   688   689   690   691   692   693   694   695   696   697   >>   >|  
is fall and the fall of Troy meant her enslavement and a life of misery. What makes the scene in question so modern is the attitude of Hector--his dividing his caresses equally between his wife and his son, and assuring her that he is more troubled about her fate and anguish than about what may befall his father, mother, and brothers. That is an utterly un-Greek sentiment, and that is the reason why the passage was not imitated. It was not a realistic scene from life, but a mere product of Homer's imagination and glowing genius--like the pathetic scene in which Odysseus wipes away a tear on noting that his faithful dog Argos recognized him and wagged his tail. It is extremely improbable that a man who could behave so cruelly toward women as Odysseus did could have thus sympathized with a dog. Certainly no one else did, not even his "faithful" Penelope. As long as Argos was useful in the chase, the poet tells us, he was well taken care of; but now that he was old, he "lay neglected upon a pile of dung," doomed to starve, for he had not strength to move. Homer alone, with the prophetic insight of a genius, could have conceived such a touch of modern sentiment toward animals, so utterly foreign to ancient ideas; and he alone could have put such a sentiment of wife-love into the mouth of the Trojan Hector--a barbarian whose ideal of manliness and greatness consisted in "bringing home blood-stained spoils of the enemy." BARBAROUS TREATMENT OF GREEK WOMEN It seems like a touch of sarcasm that Homer incarnates his isolated and un-Greek ideal of devotion to a wife in a _Trojan_, as if to indicate that it must not be accepted as a touch of _Greek_ life. From our point of view it is a stroke of genius. On the other hand it is obvious that attributing such a sentiment to a Trojan likewise cannot be anything but a poetic license; for these Trojans were quite as piratical, coarse, licentious, and polygamous as the Greeks, Hector's own father having had fifty children, nineteen of whom were borne by his wife, thirty-one by various concubines. Many pages of the _Iliad_ bear witness to the savage ferocity of Greeks and Trojans alike--a ferocity utterly incompatible with such tender emotions as Homer himself was able to conceive in his imagination. The ferocity of Achilles is typical of the feelings of these heroes. Not content with slaughtering an enemy who meets him in honorable battle, defending his wife and home, he thrust
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   648   649   650   651   652   653   654   655   656   657   658   659   660   661   662   663   664   665   666   667   668   669   670   671   672  
673   674   675   676   677   678   679   680   681   682   683   684   685   686   687   688   689   690   691   692   693   694   695   696   697   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

sentiment

 

utterly

 

genius

 

ferocity

 

Trojan

 

Hector

 
faithful
 

Greeks

 
imagination
 

Trojans


Odysseus

 
father
 
modern
 
isolated
 

devotion

 
incarnates
 

sarcasm

 
stroke
 

accepted

 

heroes


feelings
 

content

 

bringing

 

defending

 

consisted

 

greatness

 

thrust

 

manliness

 
battle
 

honorable


TREATMENT

 

BARBAROUS

 

slaughtering

 

stained

 

spoils

 

typical

 

polygamous

 

licentious

 
savage
 
coarse

witness
 

barbarian

 
concubines
 
children
 

nineteen

 
piratical
 

likewise

 

Achilles

 

attributing

 
thirty