_Robinson._ Utopia! Is it certain that we will do this rather than that?
_Friday._ Well, if we have no wants, we will rest. Is rest nothing?
_Robinson._ When one rests one dies of hunger.
_Friday._ Friend, you are in a vicious circle. I speak of a rest which
diminishes neither our gains nor our vegetables. You always forget that
by means of our commerce with this stranger, nine hours of labor will
give us as much food as twelve now do.
_Robinson._ It is easy to see that you were not reared in Europe.
Perhaps you have never read the _Moniteur Industriel_? It would have
taught you this: "All time saved is a dear loss. Eating is not the
important matter, but working. Nothing which we consume counts, if it is
not the product of our labor. Do you wish to know whether you are rich?
Do not look at your comforts, but at your trouble." This is what the
_Moniteur Industriel_ would have taught you. I, who am not a theorist,
see but the loss of our hunting.
_Friday._ What a strange perversion of ideas. But--
_Robinson._ No _buts_. Besides, there are political reasons for
rejecting the interested offers of this perfidious stranger.
_Friday._ Political reasons!
_Robinson._ Yes. In the first place he makes these offers only because
they are for his advantage.
_Friday._ So much the better, since they are for ours also.
_Robinson._ Then by these exchanges we shall become dependent on him.
_Friday._ And he on us. We need his game, he our vegetables, and we will
live in good friendship.
_Robinson._ Fancy! Do you want I should leave you without an answer?
_Friday._ Let us see; I am still waiting a good reason.
_Robinson._ Supposing that the stranger learns to cultivate a garden,
and that his island is more fertile than ours. Do you see the
consequences?
_Friday._ Yes. Our relations with the stranger will stop. He will take
no more vegetables from us, since he can get them at home with less
trouble. He will bring us no more game, since we will have nothing to
give in exchange, and we will be then just where you want us to be now.
_Robinson._ Short-sighted savage! You do not see that after having
destroyed our hunting, by inundating us with game, he will kill our
gardening by overwhelming us with vegetables.
_Friday._ But he will do that only so long as we give him _something
else_; that is to say, so long as we find _something else_ to produce,
which will economize our labor.
_Robinson._ _Something
|