ration of justice in
the case of fugitive slaves, so there have been instances at the South
where mobs and riots have disregarded the rights of citizens of
Northern States. I propose to deal fairly by all sections. Let us
remove both causes of complaint. I move to amend the seventh section
by adding thereto the following words:
"Congress shall provide by law for securing to the citizens
of each State the privileges and immunities of citizens in
the several States."
Mr. GUTHRIE:--I repeat my objection to all these amendments. If our
work here is to have any efficacy, we must adhere to the report. Why
bring in another bone of contention?
Mr. ORTH:--Will you not extend the same protection to free citizens
which you do to slaveholders?
The question was taken on the motion of Mr. FRELINGHUYSEN, with the
following result:
AYES.--Connecticut, Delaware, Indiana, Illinois, Iowa,
Maine, Massachusetts, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, New
Hampshire, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, and
Kansas--16.
NOES.--Kentucky, Missouri, North Carolina, Tennessee, and
Virginia--4.
So the amendment was adopted.
Mr. ROMAN dissented from the vote of Maryland.
Mr. AMES:--I move an amendment which will make the section more
explicit. I move to strike out the word "force," and to insert instead
thereof the words "violence or intimidation."
The motion was agreed to without objection.
Mr. ORTH:--I move to amend the seventh section by adding at the close
thereof the following words:
"And such fugitives, after such payment, shall then be
discharged from such service."
I am opposed to this whole business of making compensation for
fugitive slaves; but if this section is to be adopted, and the
Government pays the owner the whole value of the fugitive, upon every
principle of equity and justice the fugitive should be discharged, and
the master should have no right to reduce him again to slavery. You
make the measure of the owner's damages in such a case the value of
the slave. Do you intend, after he has secured that, he shall still
have the right of capture--that after the damages have been fully
paid, he may still call on the courts of law for the slave's
surrender? This would be a double compensation indeed. I shall insist
upon this amendment, and ask a vote by States.
Mr. ROMAN:--I have not hitherto addressed the Conference, but I should
do myself injustic
|