FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   133   134   135   136   137   138   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   147   148   149   150   151   152   153   154   >>  
ranii are mentioned as connexions of Lollius Urbicus (C.I.L. viii. 6705). CHAPTER 2. _Lollius Urbicus_ is described a few lines lower down as _praefectus urbi_, which is borne out by an inscription (C.I.L. vi. 28). The lawsuit of Aemilianus must therefore have been heard at Rome. The explanation of the words _quam quidem vocem_, &c., which follow, imply that Lollius was now in Numidia. This is possible enough since an inscription (C.I.L. viii. 6705) proves him to have been a native of Tiddis in Numidia. The _praefectus urbi_ was assisted by a _consilium_, not by _iudices_. Here the members of the _consilium_ are described as _consulares_. [Cp. Karlowa, Roem. Rechtgesch., p. 551.] CHAPTER 4. _not merely in Latin but also in Greek._ Cp. Florida, chaps. 18 and 26. _Tannonius Pudens_, an advocatus of the accusers and, presumably, a relative. _Homer_, sc. Il. iii. 65. _Pythagoras_, inventor of the term [Greek: philosophia]; cp. Diog. Laert. i, proem. 12. He was a native of Samos and migrated to Croton. See Florida, chap. 15. Floruit circa 530 B.C. _Zeno_ of Velia or Elea in Lucania was the founder of dialectic. Floruit circa 450 B.C. _self inconsistency._ The phrase _argumenta ambifariam dissolvere_ is very obscure. I am indebted to Professor Cook Wilson for the following note. 'A comparison of the passage with the captious argument of Protagoras (Florida, chap. 17, _ambifariam proposuit_), which is in the form of a dilemma, might suggest that _ambifariam_ in both places means "by dilemma". But this is not a natural way of describing the method of Zeno. The characteristic of his philosophy was, according to tradition, that he tried to prove the thesis of Parmenides negatively by disproving the hypothesis contradictory to it. The disproof consisted in showing that the hypothesis in question involved a contradiction. If, therefore, _ambifariam_ means "by dilemma" it would appear that Apuleius did not understand the true characteristic of Zeno's method; for _dissolvere_ should refer to Zeno's method of disproof, which is not properly called dilemma. 'But perhaps it is not necessary to assume such a mistake on the part of Apuleius. _Ambifariam_ may mean "ambiguously" in the sense of involving both sides of a contradiction (i.e. both of two contradictory propositions). This would suit the Protagoras passage well, for the argument, as the context shows, involves a contradiction. Zeno's argumentation also could b
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   133   134   135   136   137   138   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   147   148   149   150   151   152   153   154   >>  



Top keywords:

dilemma

 

ambifariam

 

Florida

 

contradiction

 

method

 

Lollius

 

Protagoras

 
native
 

Apuleius

 

passage


dissolvere
 

Floruit

 

Numidia

 

argument

 
hypothesis
 
characteristic
 

disproof

 

contradictory

 

consilium

 

CHAPTER


inscription

 

Urbicus

 

praefectus

 

proposuit

 
context
 

suggest

 

describing

 
propositions
 

natural

 

places


involves

 

Wilson

 

Professor

 

indebted

 

captious

 

argumentation

 

comparison

 

obscure

 
Ambifariam
 

mistake


understand

 

properly

 

assume

 

involved

 

thesis

 

Parmenides

 

philosophy

 

called

 
tradition
 

negatively