the _matter_ expressed. A little thought will soon convince any person
accustomed to these subjects that _conjunctions always connect words, not
propositions_. The only work in which I leave seen Dr. Latham's fundamental
error exposed, is in Boole's _Mathematical Analysis of Logic_; the learned
author, though he seems unsettled on many matters of logic and metaphysics,
has clearly made up his mind on the point now under discussion. He says:
"The proposition, every animal is _either_ rational _or_ irrational,
cannot be resolved into, _Either_ every animal is rational, _or_ every
animal is irrational. The former belong to pure categoricals, to latter
to hypotheticals [Query _disjunctives_]. In _singular_ propositions
such conversions would seem to be allowable. This animal is _either_
rational _or_ irrational, is equivalent to, _Either_ this animal is
rational, _or_ it is irrational. This peculiarity of _singular_
propositions would almost justify our ranking them, though truly
universals, in a separate class, as Ramus and his followers did."--P.
59.
This certainly seems unanswerable.
If Dr. Latham is a reader of "N. & Q.," I should be glad if he would give
his reasons for adhering to his original doctrine in the face of such facts
as those I have instanced.
C. MANSFIELD INGLEBY.
Birmingham.
* * * * *
THE CORONET [CROWN] OF LLEWELYN AP GRIFFITH, PRINCE OF WALES.
A notice, transferred to _The Times_ of the 5th instant from a recent
number of _The Builder_, on the shrine of Edward the Confessor, after
mentioning that "to this shrine Edward I. offered the Scottish regalia and
the coronation chair, which is still preserved," adds, "Alphonso, about
1280, offered it the golden coronet of Llewelyn, Prince of Wales, and other
jewels."
Who was Alphonso? And would the contributor of the notice favour the
readers of "N. & Q." with the authority _in extenso_ for the offering of
this coronet?
The period assigned for the offering is certainly too early; Llewelyn ap
Griffith, "the last sovereign of one of the most ancient ruling families of
Europe" (_Hist. of England_, by Sir James Mackintosh, vol. ii. p. 254.),
having been slain at Builth, Dec. 11, 1282. Warrington (_Hist. of. Wales_,
vol. ii. p. 271.), on the authority of Rymer's _Foedera_, vol. ii. p. 224.,
says: "Upon stripping Llewelyn there were found his Privy Seal; a paper
that was fill
|