FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36   37  
38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   >>  
ation in both is one and identical in kind: the origin of either is from an egg, or at least something that by analogy is held to be so. An egg is, as already said, a conception exposed beyond the body of the parent, whence the embryo is produced; a conception is an egg remaining within the body of the parent until the foetus has acquired the requisite perfection; in everything else they agree; they are both alike primordially vegetables, potentially they are animals.[23] The ovum, for Harvey, is in essence "the primordium vegetable or vegetative incipience, understanding by this a certain corporeal something having life in potentia; or a certain something existing _per se_, which is capable of changing into a vegetative form under the agency of an internal principle."[24] The ovum is for Harvey more a concept than an observed fact, and, as stated by one student of generation, "The _dictum ex ovo omnia_, whilst substantially true in the modern sense, is neither true nor false as employed by Harvey, since to him it has no definite or even intelligible meaning."[25] Harvey's treatise on generation is clearly a product of his time. It advances embryology by its demonstration of certain facts of development, by its aggressive espousal of epigenesis and the origin of all animals from eggs, and by its dynamic approach stressing the temporal factors in development and the initial independent function of embryonic organs. However, the strong Aristotelian cast of Harvey's treatise encouraged continued discussion of long outdated questions in an outdated manner and, combined with his expressed disdain for "chymistry" and atomism, discouraged close cooperation between embryologists of different persuasions. It is perhaps easy to underestimate the impact and general importance of Harvey's work in view of these qualifications, and so it should be remarked that both positive and negative features of _De Generatione_ influenced profoundly subsequent embryological thought. It will be recalled that the title of _The Philosophicall Touch-Stone_ identified Digby as the object of Alexander Ross's ire. In comparable manner, the latter's _Arcana Microcosmi_, published in 1652, declares its purpose to be "a refutation of Dr. Brown's Vulgar Errors, the Lord Bacon's Natural History, and Dr. Harvy's book _De Generatione_." Let us pause a brief moment in memory of a man so intrepid as to undertake the refu
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36   37  
38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   >>  



Top keywords:

Harvey

 

manner

 
outdated
 

generation

 

Generatione

 

vegetative

 

animals

 

treatise

 

conception

 

development


origin
 
parent
 
persuasions
 

underestimate

 

embryologists

 

discussion

 
initial
 

factors

 

impact

 

qualifications


temporal
 

general

 

importance

 

continued

 

cooperation

 

independent

 

However

 

expressed

 

strong

 

combined


questions
 

Aristotelian

 

disdain

 

organs

 

atomism

 

discouraged

 

encouraged

 

function

 

chymistry

 

embryonic


identified
 

Errors

 

Vulgar

 

Natural

 

refutation

 
published
 

declares

 

purpose

 

History

 

memory