FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   390   391   392   393   394   395   396   397   398   399   400   401   402   403   404   405   406   407   408   409   410   411   412   413   414  
415   416   417   418   419   420   421   422   423   424   425   426   427   428   429   430   431   432   433   434   435   436   437   438   439   >>   >|  
uch-disputed question I must not go farther, except to note that while Heinze is absolutely confident that Virgil never wrote these lines, the editor of the new Oxford text of Virgil is equally certain that he did. My opinion is of no value on such a point; but I am disposed to agree with Mr. Hirtzel that "versus valde Vergilianos, ab optimis codicibus omissos, iniuria obleverunt Tucca et Varius." They are certainly in keeping with the picture of Aeneas' _impotentia_ which is generally suggested in Book ii. If it should be argued that this _impotentia_, _i.e._ want of self-control, is only put into the mouth of Aeneas in order to heighten the effect of his stirring narrative, it will be well to remember the remonstrances of Venus, which make such a hypothesis impossible. [890] _Op. cit._ p. 231. [891] _Vergils epische Technik_, p. 113 foll. [892] The original story was, that unable to escape from an enforced marriage with Iarbas, she killed herself to mark her unflinching faithfulness to her first husband Sicharbas. Servius quotes Varro as stating that it was not Dido, but Anna who committed suicide for love of Aeneas (on _Aen._ iv. 682); and as Varro died before the Aeneid was begun, this may be taken as proving that Virgil's version of the love-story was not his own invention. But it is quite possible that Servius here only means that Varro's version differed in this point from that which the poet soon afterwards adopted; it may be that the story in the poem is thus practically his own. [893] _Op. cit._ p. 116. [894] _Ancient Lives of Vergil_, Clarendon Press, 1879. [895] The critics have, I think, been weaker in dealing with the fifth book than with any of the others. Prof. Tyrrell is too violent in his contempt for it to admit of quotation here. Heinze has some good and acute remarks on Virgil's motive in placing the book where it is, but seems to me to miss the real importance of it (_op. cit._ 140 foll.). Even Boissier, whose delightful account of the scenery of Eryx should be read by every one who would appreciate this book (_op. cit._ p. 232), goes so far as to say that it is the one book with which we feel we might easily dispense so far as the story is concerned. [896] _Roman Festivals_, p. 307. [897] _Op. cit
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   390   391   392   393   394   395   396   397   398   399   400   401   402   403   404   405   406   407   408   409   410   411   412   413   414  
415   416   417   418   419   420   421   422   423   424   425   426   427   428   429   430   431   432   433   434   435   436   437   438   439   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

Virgil

 

Aeneas

 
impotentia
 

Heinze

 

Servius

 

version

 

practically

 

Vergil

 

Ancient

 

Clarendon


invention

 
Aeneid
 
committed
 

suicide

 
proving
 

adopted

 

differed

 

scenery

 

account

 

Boissier


delightful

 

Festivals

 

concerned

 

dispense

 
easily
 

importance

 
Tyrrell
 

violent

 

weaker

 

dealing


contempt

 
placing
 

motive

 

remarks

 

quotation

 
critics
 

enforced

 
Vergilianos
 

optimis

 

codicibus


versus

 

Hirtzel

 
disposed
 

omissos

 

iniuria

 
keeping
 

picture

 
generally
 

suggested

 

obleverunt