FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1285   1286   1287   1288   1289   1290   1291   1292   1293   1294   1295   1296   1297   1298   1299   1300   1301   1302   1303   1304   1305   1306   1307   1308   1309  
1310   1311   1312   1313   1314   1315   1316   1317   1318   1319   1320   1321   1322   1323   1324   1325   1326   1327   1328   1329   1330   1331   1332   1333   1334   >>   >|  
e _needs_ not _proceed_."--_Murray's Key_, 8vo, p. 180. OBS. 14.--On questions of grammar, the _practice of authors_ ought to be of more weight, than the _dogmatism of grammarians_; but it is often difficult to decide well by either; because errors and contradictions abound in both. For example: Dr. Blair says, (in speaking of the persons represented by _I_ and _thou_,) "Their sex _needs_ not _be_ marked."--_Rhet._, p. 79. Jamieson abridges the work, and says, "_needs_ not _to_ be marked."--_Gram. of Rhet._, p. 28. Dr. Lowth also says, "_needs_ not _be_ marked."--_Gram._, p. 21. Churchill enlarges the work, and says, "_needs_ not _to_ be marked."--_New Gram._, p. 72. Lindley Murray copies Lowth, and says, "_needs_ not _be_ marked."--_Gram._, 12mo, 2d Ed., p. 39; 23d Ed., p. 51; and perhaps all other editions. He afterwards enlarges his own work, and says, "_needs_ not _to_ be marked."--_Octavo Gram._, p. 51. But, according to Greenleaf they all express the idea ungrammatically; the only true form being, "Their sex _need_ not _be marked_." See _Gram. Simplified_, p. 48. In the two places in which the etymology and the syntax of this verb are examined, I have cited from proper sources more than twenty examples in which _to_ is used after it, and more than twenty others in which the verb is not inflected in the third person singular. In the latter, _need_ is treated as an auxiliary; in the former, it is a principal verb, of the regular construction. If the principal verb _need_ can also govern the infinitive without _to_, as all our grammarians have supposed, then there is a third form which is unobjectionable, and my pupils may take their choice of the three. But still there is a fourth form which nobody approves, though the hands of some great men have furnished us with examples of it: as, "A figure of thought _need_ not _to_ detort the words from their literal sense."--_J. Q. Adams's Lectures_, Vol. ii, p. 254. "Which a man _need_ only _to_ appeal to his own feelings immediately to evince."--_Clarkson's Prize-Essay on Slavery_, p. 106. OBS. 15.--Webster and Greenleaf seem inclined to justify the use of _dare_, as well as of _need_, for the third person singular. Their doctrine is this: "In _popular practice_ it is used in the third person, without the personal termination. Thus, instead of saying, 'He _dares_ not do it;' WE _generally_ say, 'He _dare_ not do it.' In like manner, _need_, when an active verb, is regular
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1285   1286   1287   1288   1289   1290   1291   1292   1293   1294   1295   1296   1297   1298   1299   1300   1301   1302   1303   1304   1305   1306   1307   1308   1309  
1310   1311   1312   1313   1314   1315   1316   1317   1318   1319   1320   1321   1322   1323   1324   1325   1326   1327   1328   1329   1330   1331   1332   1333   1334   >>   >|  



Top keywords:
marked
 

person

 
singular
 
regular
 

principal

 

examples

 

Greenleaf

 

twenty

 

enlarges

 
grammarians

practice

 

Murray

 
popular
 
active
 
termination
 

choice

 
infinitive
 
personal
 

govern

 

approves


doctrine

 

fourth

 

generally

 

supposed

 

manner

 
unobjectionable
 
pupils
 

Lectures

 

immediately

 

evince


feelings
 
Slavery
 

appeal

 

figure

 
Clarkson
 
furnished
 

justify

 

inclined

 

Webster

 
literal

detort

 

thought

 

etymology

 
speaking
 

errors

 
contradictions
 

abound

 

persons

 

represented

 

Churchill