FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   498   499   500   501   502   503   504   505   506   507   508   509   510   511   512   513   514   515   516   517   518   519   520   521   522  
523   524   525   526   527   528   529   530   531   532   533   534   535   536   537   538   539   540   541   542   543   544   545   546   547   >>   >|  
e course of the common law." I suggest that the common law is referred to as fixing a right simply. The course of the common law is a phrase defined for more than two hundred years, in Latin, in English, and in Norman French. It means the formula of proceeding. I understood the Senator from Virginia [Mr. MASON] to say that it had been decided in several of the courts that an action of trover could not be brought for a negro slave in England. I think I am familiar with the case. It is reported in Salkeld's Reports, Lord Raymond's Reports, and in the Modern Reports--the same case reported three times; but the same court which decided that trover would not lie, because trover included the idea of property in the man himself, in the same opinion said that trespass on the case would lie for the loss of the service; so that it was all a question of pleading, and no question of right at all. It is within my recollection--and I believe the case was brought to the Supreme Court on a writ of error, and can be found in Howard's Reports--that a citizen of Kentucky declared in trespass on the case for taking away his slaves, and added two counts in trover. What is trover but an action of trespass on the case? Nothing more; and it never was any thing more. The measure of damages is the same in both actions--the value of the service of the servant; and yet that controversy on mere pleading--which, in nine-tenths of the States of this Union, has ceased to be of any value, because they have a code of procedure, is made a terrific objection here. Now, sir, I have never read the code of New Mexico, and I do not propose to read it; but it is perfectly understood that that Territorial Legislature, pursuing the privilege, if you call it privilege, conferred by the compromise measures of 1850, has established the relation of master and slave, or master and servant, as perfectly as it is established in any of the fifteen so-called slaveholding States. I do not admire this word "_status_" which we find in the report of the Peace Conference; but as to the meaning of that word, I cannot be in any doubt. It does not refer to any persons in particular; it refers to a legal relation of servitude as between master and servant, and it provides that that relation, or condition, or _status_, shall not be changed; that for all wrongs or controversies arising out of that there shall be a remedy through the Federal judiciary. I can see why the commi
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   498   499   500   501   502   503   504   505   506   507   508   509   510   511   512   513   514   515   516   517   518   519   520   521   522  
523   524   525   526   527   528   529   530   531   532   533   534   535   536   537   538   539   540   541   542   543   544   545   546   547   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

trover

 

Reports

 

master

 

servant

 

common

 

relation

 
trespass
 
status
 

perfectly

 

brought


service

 
question
 

privilege

 

pleading

 
established
 

reported

 

States

 
action
 

understood

 

decided


propose

 

tenths

 

Mexico

 
Territorial
 

procedure

 
terrific
 

pursuing

 

ceased

 

Legislature

 

objection


fifteen

 

condition

 

changed

 

wrongs

 

servitude

 

refers

 

controversies

 

Federal

 

judiciary

 

remedy


arising
 

persons

 

called

 

slaveholding

 

admire

 

controversy

 

measures

 

conferred

 

compromise

 

meaning