erbear, break in pieces, and become almost
worthless. With proper care and thinning when too thick we can partially
overcome this.

W. J. Griffing: It is my second best apple. I consider the Winesap the
best, as it has paid me the best, and I am planting for winter profit
only these two. All apple trees die young with us.

F. W. Dixon: I can add nothing new, but place it second on the list.

James Sharp: It has been my most profitable variety. About four-fifths
have been marketable. As to dying young, I would rather grow new ones.

President Wellhouse: We will have to stick to it awhile yet in Kansas.
When of good size they command a price in advance of the Ben Davis.

G. P. Whiteker: It gives good satisfaction as a commercial apple. It
bears young; and you can get good returns for eight or ten years, and
then put out a new orchard.

Phillip Lux: I would place the Missouri Pippin second on the commercial
list.

William Cutter: It is the youngest to bear. It is a Western apple. Other
varieties gradually die out, but it sticks. The farther west you go the
better it is. It stands drought and wind best of all. While it breaks
off on the top, it is not a short-lived tree.

B. F. Smith: I would place it second on the commercial list.

GANO.

Origin, Howard county, Missouri. Tree very hardy; has never been injured
by the cold winters; bears very young, roots readily from its own stock,
and can almost be grown from a cutting. Fruit bright red on yellow
ground, no stripes; large, oblong, tapering to the eye; surface smooth,
takes a very high polish, making it valuable as a stand fruit, thought
by many to surpass the Ben Davis. Minute dots; basin shallow, sometimes
deep; stem medium to long; flesh white, fine grained, tender, mild,
pleasant subacid. An early, annual and prolific bearer. December to May.

Remarks on the Gano by members of the State Horticultural Society:

W. G. Gano: I cannot be against my namesake. I have found nothing yet
that excels the parent trees. The Gano is creating a sensation, more
especially in the southern part of Missouri. They prefer it to Ben
Davis, and, where extensively planted and in bearing, it is creating a
sensation. While I have no interest in it, other than the name, still I
think we have in the Gano something that will stay. It is much like Ben
Davis.

E. J. Holman: I would class it and the Ben Davis as twins.

James Sharp: I planted about 700 trees of it five years ago. T