FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67   68   69   70   71   72   73   74   75   76   77   78  
79   80   81   82   83   >>  
ferred_ from the nature of commerce." "No rule," continued Lord Hardwicke, "can be more settled than that testimony is not to be received but upon oath"; but he lays it down, that an oath itself may be dispensed with. "There is another instance," says he, "where the lawful oath may be dispensed with,--where our courts admit evidence for the Crown without oath." In the same discussion, the Chief-Baron (Parker) cited cases in which _all_ the rules of evidence had given way. "There is not a more general rule," says he, "than that hearsay cannot be admitted, nor husband and wife as witnesses against each other; and yet it is _notorious_ that from necessity they have been allowed,--not an _absolute_ necessity, but a _moral_ one." It is further remarkable, in this judicial argument, that exceptions are allowed not only to rules of evidence, but that the rules of evidence themselves are not altogether the same, where the subject-matter varies. The Judges have, to facilitate justice, and to favor commerce, even adopted the rules of _foreign_ laws. They have taken for granted, and would not suffer to be questioned, the regularity and justice of the proceedings of foreign courts; and they have admitted them as evidence, not only of the fact of the decision, but of the right as to its legality. "Where there are foreign parties interested, and in commercial matters, the rules of evidence are not quite the same as in other instances in courts of justice: the case of Hue and Cry, Brownlow, 47. A feme covert is not a lawful witness against her husband, except in cases of treason, but has been admitted in civil cases.[53] The testimony of a public notary is evidence by the law of France: contracts are made before a public notary, and no other witness necessary. I should think it would be no doubt at all, if it came in question here, whether this would be a valid contract, but a testimony from persons of that credit and reputation would be received as a very good proof in foreign transactions, and would authenticate the contract."[54] These cases show that courts always govern themselves by these rules in cases of foreign transactions. To this principle Lord Hardwicke accords; and enlarging the rule of evidence by the nature of the subject and the exigencies of the case, he lays it down, "that it is a common and _natural_ presumption, that persons of the Gentoo religion should be principally apprised of facts and transactions in th
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67   68   69   70   71   72   73   74   75   76   77   78  
79   80   81   82   83   >>  



Top keywords:
evidence
 
foreign
 
courts
 
transactions
 

justice

 

admitted

 

testimony

 

necessity

 

dispensed

 

allowed


contract

 

nature

 

husband

 

persons

 

commerce

 

notary

 

public

 
witness
 
Hardwicke
 

subject


received

 

lawful

 
common
 

natural

 

contracts

 

exigencies

 
France
 

principally

 

apprised

 
Brownlow

instances

 
presumption
 

treason

 

covert

 
govern
 

Gentoo

 

credit

 

matters

 

reputation

 

accords


authenticate

 
religion
 
principle
 

question

 

enlarging

 

altogether

 

general

 

Parker

 

hearsay

 
notorious