FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   286   287   288   289   290   291   292   293   294   295   296   297   298   299   300   301   302   303   304   305   306   307   308   309   310  
311   312   >>  
s, and Bulgarians, who walk through fire unhurt. It is not necessary to believe Sir W. Crookes's assertions that he saw Home perform the fire-tricks, for we can fall back on the lack of light (only two candles and the fire-light), as also on the law of hallucination caused by excitement. But it _is_ necessary to believe this distinguished authority's statement about his ignorance of 'some non-conducting substance:' 'Schoolboys' books and mediaeval tales describe how this can be done with alum and other ingredients. It is possible that the skin may be so hardened and thickened by such preparations that superficial charring might take place without the pain becoming great; but the surface of the skin would certainly suffer severely. After Home had recovered from the trance, I examined his hand with care to see if there were any signs of burning or of previous preparation. I could detect no trace or injury to the skin, which was soft and delicate, like a woman's. Neither were there signs of any preparation having been previously applied. I have often seen conjurers and others handle red-hot coals and iron, but there were always palpable signs of burning.'[11] In September 1897 a crew of passengers went from New Zealand to see the Fijian rites, which, as reported in the 'Fiji Times,' corresponded exactly with the description published by Mr. Basil Thomson, himself a witness. The interesting point, historically, is the combination in Home of all the _repertoire_ of the possessed men in Iamblichus. We certainly cannot get rid of the fire-trick by aid of a hypothetical 'non-conducting substance.' Till the 'substance' is tested experimentally it is not a _vera causa_. We might as well say 'spirits' at once. Both that 'substance' and those 'spirits' are equally 'in the air.' Yet Mr. Podmore's 'explanations' (not satisfactory to himself) are conceived so thoroughly in the spirit of popular science--one of them casually discovering a new psychological law, a second contradicting the facts it seeks to account for, a third generously inventing an unknown substance--that they ought to be welcomed by reviewers and lecturers. It seems wiser to admit our ignorance and suspend our belief. Here closes the futile chapter of explanations. Fraud is a _vera causa_, but an hypothesis difficult of application when it is admitted that the effects could not be caused by ordinary mechanical means. Hallucination, through excitement, is a _
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   286   287   288   289   290   291   292   293   294   295   296   297   298   299   300   301   302   303   304   305   306   307   308   309   310  
311   312   >>  



Top keywords:

substance

 

ignorance

 
preparation
 

conducting

 

spirits

 

burning

 
explanations
 
excitement
 

caused

 

ordinary


Iamblichus
 
admitted
 
application
 

difficult

 

experimentally

 

effects

 
possessed
 

tested

 

reviewers

 

hypothetical


corresponded

 

description

 

published

 

Fijian

 

reported

 

Hallucination

 

historically

 

combination

 

hypothesis

 

interesting


Thomson

 

mechanical

 

witness

 

repertoire

 

chapter

 
casually
 
Zealand
 

discovering

 

spirit

 

popular


science
 
psychological
 

account

 

generously

 

inventing

 

contradicting

 
conceived
 

closes

 
welcomed
 

futile