FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   >>  
r they were afraid.' In some copies, however, this also is added,--'Now when He was risen,' &c. This, however, seems to contradict to some extent what was before delivered," &c. It may sound fabulous, but it is strictly true, that every word of this, (unsuspiciously adopted as it has been by _every Critic_ who has since gone over the same ground,) is a mere tissue of mistakes. For first,--Cod. 23 contains _nothing whatever pertinent to the present inquiry_. (Scholz, evidently through haste and inadvertence, has confounded _his own_ "23" with "_Coisl._ 23," but "Coisl. 23" is his "39,"--of which by-and-by. This reference therefore has to be cancelled.)--Cod. 41 contains a scholion of _precisely the opposite tendency_: I mean, a scholion which avers that _the accurate copies of S. Mark's Gospel contain these last twelve verses_. (Scholz borrowed this wrong reference from Wetstein,--who, by an oversight, quotes Cod. 41 three times instead of twice.)--There remain but Codd. 34 and 39; and in neither of those two manuscripts, from the first page of S. Mark's Gospel to the last, does there exist _any _"scholion of Severus of Antioch"_ whatever_. Scholz, in a word, has inadvertently made a gross misstatement;(208) and every Critic who has since written on this subject has adopted his words,--without acknowledgment and without examination.... Such is the evidence on which it is proposed to prove that S. Mark did not write the last twelve verses of his Gospel! (7.) Scholz proceeds to enumerate the following twenty-two Codices:--24, 34, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 108, 129, 137, 138, 143, 181, 186, 195, 199, 206, 209, 210, 221, 222. And this imposing catalogue is what has misled Tischendorf, Tregelles and the rest. They have not perceived that it is _a mere transcript of Griesbach's list_; which Scholz interrupts only to give from Cod. 24, (imperfectly and at second-hand,) the weighty scholion, (Wetstein had given it from Cod. 41,) which relates, on the authority of an eye-witness, that S. Mark xvi. 9-20 existed in the ancient Palestinian Copy. (About that Scholion enough has been offered already.(209)) Scholz adds that very nearly the same words are found in 374.--What he says concerning 206 and 209 (and he might have added 199,) has been explained above. But when the twenty MSS. which remain(210) undisposed of have been scrutinized, their testimony is found to be quite different from what is commonly supposed. One of
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   >>  



Top keywords:
Scholz
 

scholion

 

Gospel

 
reference
 
copies
 
remain
 

adopted

 

verses

 

twelve

 

twenty


Wetstein
 
Critic
 

misled

 

Griesbach

 

perceived

 

transcript

 

interrupts

 

Tregelles

 

Tischendorf

 

enumerate


Codices
 

imposing

 

catalogue

 
witness
 

explained

 
commonly
 
supposed
 

testimony

 

undisposed

 

scrutinized


offered

 

relates

 
authority
 
weighty
 

imperfectly

 
proceeds
 

Scholion

 

Palestinian

 

ancient

 

existed


inadvertently

 

inadvertence

 
confounded
 

evidently

 
pertinent
 
present
 

inquiry

 

opposite

 
tendency
 

precisely