FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   146   >>  
ose of Eusebius; and yet, (3dly.) Who sees not that unless the Sections of Ammonius and those of Eusebius can be proved to have corresponded throughout, the name of Ammonius has no business whatever to be introduced into such a discussion as the present? They must at least be told that in the entire absence of proof of any kind,--(and certainly nothing that Eusebius says warrants any such inference,(226))--to reason from the one to the other as if they were identical, is what no sincere inquirer after Truth is permitted to do. It is time, however, that I should plainly declare that it happens to be no matter of opinion at all whether the lost Sections of Ammonius were identical with those of Eusebius or not. It is demonstrable that they _cannot_ have been so; and the proof is supplied by the Sections themselves. It is discovered, by a careful inspection of them, that they _imply_ and _presuppose the Ten Canons_; being in many places even meaningless,--nugatory, in fact, (I do not of course say that they are _practically_ without _use_,)--except on the theory that those Canons were already in existence.(227) Now the Canons are confessedly the invention of Eusebius. He distinctly claims them.(228) Thus much then concerning the supposed testimony of Ammonius. It is _nil_.--And now for what is alleged concerning the evidence of Eusebius. The starting-point of this discussion, (as I began by remarking), is the following memorandum found in certain ancient MSS.:--"Thus far did Eusebius canonize;"(229) which means either: (1) That his Canons recognise no section of S. Mark's Gospel subsequent to
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   146   >>  



Top keywords:

Eusebius

 
Ammonius
 

Canons

 

Sections

 

discussion

 

identical

 
places
 

meaningless

 

nugatory

 

claims


existence
 
theory
 

invention

 

supposed

 

practically

 

confessedly

 

distinctly

 
canonize
 
Gospel
 

subsequent


recognise
 
section
 

ancient

 

alleged

 

evidence

 

starting

 
memorandum
 
remarking
 

testimony

 

entire


absence

 

reason

 
inference
 

warrants

 

present

 

proved

 

corresponded

 
introduced
 

business

 

demonstrable


supplied
 
presuppose
 

inspection

 
careful
 
discovered
 

opinion

 

permitted

 
inquirer
 

sincere

 
matter