FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   425   426   427   428   429   430   431   432   433   434   435   436   437   438   439   440   441   442   443   444   445   446   447   448   449  
450   451   452   453   454   455   456   457   458   459   460   461   462   463   464   465   466   467   468   469   470   471   472   473   474   >>   >|  
aegyptoque." Take this third sentence:-- "Neque vero ornamenta ista villarum, quibus Lucium Paullum et Lucium Mummium, qui rebus his urbem Italiamque omnem referserunt, ab aliquo video perfacile Deliaco aut Syro potuisse superari." Place the words thus:-- "Potuisse superari ab aliquo Syro aut Deliaco." Do you not see that by making this slight change in the order of the words, the very same words (though the sense remains as it was before) lose all their effect the moment they are disjoined from those which were best suited to them? Or if you take any carelessly-constructed sentence of any unpolished orator, and reduce it into proper shape, by making a slight alteration in the order of his words, then that will be made harmonious which was before loose and unmethodical Come now, take a sentence from the speech of Gracchus before the censors:-- "Obesse non potest, quin ejusdem hominis sit, probos improbare, qui improbos probet." How much better would it have been if he had said, "Quin ejusdem hominis sit, qui improbos probet, probos improbare!" No one ever had any objection to speaking in this manner; and no one was ever able to do so who did not do it. But those who have spoken in a different manner have not been able to arrive at this excellence. And so on a sudden they have set up for orators of the Attic school. As if Demosthenes was a man of Tralles; but even his thunderbolts would not have shone so if they had not been pointed by rhythm. LXXI. But if there be any one who prefers a loose style of oratory, let him cultivate it; keeping in view this principle,--if any one were to take to pieces the shield of Phidias, he would destroy the beauty of the collective arrangement, not the exquisite workmanship of each fragment: and as in Thucydides I only miss the roundness of his periods; all the graces of style are there. But these men, when they compose a loose oration, in which there is no matter, and no expression which is not a low one, appear to me to be taking to pieces, not a shield, but, as the proverb says, (which, though but a low one, is still very apt,) only a broom. And in order that there may be no mistake as to their contempt of this style which I am praising, let them write something either in the style of Isocrates, or in that which Aeschines or Demosthenes employs, and then I will believe that they have not shrunk from this style out of despair of being able to arrive at it, but
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   425   426   427   428   429   430   431   432   433   434   435   436   437   438   439   440   441   442   443   444   445   446   447   448   449  
450   451   452   453   454   455   456   457   458   459   460   461   462   463   464   465   466   467   468   469   470   471   472   473   474   >>   >|  



Top keywords:
sentence
 

manner

 
arrive
 

Demosthenes

 

hominis

 

ejusdem

 
pieces
 

probos

 
probet
 
improbare

shield

 

improbos

 

slight

 

Lucium

 

Deliaco

 
aliquo
 

making

 

superari

 

beauty

 

collective


Thucydides

 

destroy

 
workmanship
 

fragment

 
exquisite
 

arrangement

 
rhythm
 

prefers

 

pointed

 
Paullum

thunderbolts
 

quibus

 

oratory

 

principle

 

ornamenta

 

keeping

 

villarum

 

cultivate

 

Phidias

 

praising


mistake

 

contempt

 

Isocrates

 
aegyptoque
 
despair
 

shrunk

 

Aeschines

 

employs

 

compose

 
oration