he independence and constitutional powers of
the Executive by providing an easy and effective way of constraining
Executive discretion. Although of late this practice has been resorted
to by all political parties when clothed with power, it did not
prevail until forty years after the adoption of the Constitution, and
it is confidently believed that it is condemned by the enlightened
judgment of the country. The States which have adopted new
constitutions during the last quarter of a century have generally
provided remedies for the evil. Many of them have enacted that no law
shall contain more than one subject, which shall be plainly expressed
in its title. The constitutions of more than half of the States
contain substantially this provision, or some other of like intent and
meaning. The public welfare will be promoted in many ways by a return
to the early practice of the Government and to the true rule of
legislation, which is that every measure should stand upon its own
merits.
I am firmly convinced that appropriation bills ought not to contain
any legislation not relevant to the application or expenditure of the
money thereby appropriated, and that by a strict adherence to this
principle an important and much needed reform will be accomplished.
Placing my objection to the bill on this feature of its frame,
I forbear any comment upon the important general and permanent
legislation which it contains, as matter for specific and independent
consideration.
RUTHERFORD B. HAYES.
EXECUTIVE MANSION, _June 15, 1880_.
_To the Senate of the United States_:
After mature consideration of the bill entitled "An act regulating the
pay and appointment of deputy marshals," I am constrained to withhold
from it my approval, and to return it to the Senate, in which it
originated, with my objections to its passage.
The laws now in force on the subject of the bill before me are
contained in the following sections of the Revised Statutes:
SEC. 2021. Whenever an election at which Representatives or
Delegates in Congress are to be chosen is held in any city
or town of 20,000 inhabitants or upward, the marshal for the
district in which the city or town is situated shall, on the
application in writing of at least two citizens residing in
such city or town, appoint special deputy marshals, whose
duty it shall be, when required thereto, to aid and assist
the supervisors of election in the verification of any
|