re
deeply imbedded in the _Odyssey_ than in the _Iliad_. I am inclined to
agree with those who believe that our _Odyssey_ was very largely
composed in Athens, so that in most of the poem Athena is original. (Cf.
O. Seeck, _Die Quellen der Odyssee_ (1887), pp. 366-420; Muelder, _Die
Ilias and ihre Quellen_ (1910), pp. 350-5.) In some parts of the _Iliad_
the name Athena may well have been substituted for some Northern goddess
whose name is now lost.
[53:2] It is worth noting also that this Homeric triad seems also to be
recognized as the chief Athenian triad. Plato, _Euthyd._ 302 c, quoted
above, continues: _Socrates._ 'We have Zeus with the names Herkeios and
Phratrios, but not Patroos, and Athena Phratria.' _Dionysodorus._ 'Well
that is enough. You have, apparently, Apollo and Zeus and Athena?'
_Socrates._ 'Certainly.'--Apollo is put first because he has been
accepted as Patroos. But see _R. G. E._,{3} p. 49, n.
[54:1] Ridgeway, _Origin and Influence of the Thoroughbred Horse_, 1905,
pp. 287-93; and _Early Age of Greece_, 1901, p. 223.
[54:2] Cf. Plut. _Q. Conv._ ix. 6; Paus. ii. 1. 6; 4. 6; 15. 5; 30. 6.
[54:3] So in the non-Homeric tradition, Eur. _Troades_ init. In the
_Iliad_ he is made an enemy of Troy, like Athena, who is none the less
the Guardian of the city.
[56:1] _Od._ +th+ 339 ff.
[56:2] See Paus. viii. 32. 4. _Themis_, pp. 295, 296.
[56:3] For the connexion of +Hera eros Herakles+ (+Herykalos+ in
Sophron, fr. 142 K) see especially A. B. Cook, _Class. Review_, 1906,
pp. 365 and 416. The name +Hera+ seems probably to be an 'ablaut' form
of +hora+: cf. phrases like +Hera teleia+. Other literature in Gruppe,
pp. 452, 1122.
[57:1] _Prolegomena_, p. 315, referring to H. D. Mueller, _Mythologie d.
gr. Staemme_, pp. 249-55. Another view is suggested by Muelder, _Die Ilias
und ihre Quellen_, p. 136. The jealous Hera comes from the
Heracles-saga, in which the wife hated the bastard.
[57:2] P. Gardner, in _Numismatic Chronicle_, N.S. xx, 'Ares as a
Sun-God'.
[57:3] Chadwick, _Heroic Age_, especially pp. 414, 459-63.
[59:1] Chap. xviii.
[59:2] Introduction to his edition of the _Choephoroe_, p. 9.
[61:1] The spirit appears very simply in Eur. _Iph. Taur._ 386 ff.,
where Iphigenia rejects the gods who demand human sacrifice:
These tales be false, false as those feastings wild
Of Tantalus, and gods that tare a child.
This land of murderers to its gods hath given
Its o
|