FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   824   825   826   827   828   829   830   831   832   833   834   835   836   837   838   839   840   841   842   843   844   845   846   847   848  
849   850   851   852   853   854   855   856   857   858   859   860   861   862   863   864   865   866   867   868   869   870   871   872   873   >>   >|  
loves, even as the Apostle swore (2 Cor. 1:23), saying: "I call God to witness upon my soul." As to Joseph's oath by the health of Pharaoh this may be understood in both ways: either by way of a curse, as though he pledged Pharao's health to God; or by way of contestation, as though he appealed to the truth of God's justice which the princes of the earth are appointed to execute. Reply Obj. 1: Our Lord forbade us to swear by creatures so as to give them the reverence due to God. Hence Jerome adds that "the Jews, through swearing by the angels and the like, worshipped creatures with a Divine honor." In the same sense a cleric is punished, according to the canons (22, qu. i, can. Clericum, Obj. 2), for swearing by a creature, for this savors of the blasphemy of unbelief. Hence in the next chapter, it is said: "If any one swears by God's hair or head, or otherwise utter blasphemy against God, and he be in ecclesiastical orders, let him be degraded." This suffices for the Reply to the Second Objection. Reply Obj. 3: Religious worship is shown to one whose testimony is invoked by oath: hence the prohibition (Ex. 23:13): "By the name of strange gods you shall not swear." But religious worship is not given to creatures employed in an oath in the ways mentioned above. _______________________ SEVENTH ARTICLE [II-II, Q. 89, Art. 7] Whether an Oath Has a Binding Force? Objection 1: It would seem that an oath has no binding force. An oath is employed in order to confirm the truth of an assertion. But when a person makes an assertion about the future his assertion is true, though it may not be verified. Thus Paul lied not (2 Cor. 1:15, seqq.) though he went not to Corinth, as he had said he would (1 Cor. 16:5). Therefore it seems that an oath is not binding. Obj. 2: Further, virtue is not contrary to virtue (Categ. viii, 22). Now an oath is an act of virtue, as stated above (A. 4). But it would sometimes be contrary to virtue, or an obstacle thereto, if one were to fulfil what one has sworn to do: for instance, if one were to swear to commit a sin, or to desist from some virtuous action. Therefore an oath is not always binding. Obj. 3: Further, sometimes a man is compelled against his will to promise something under oath. Now, "such a person is loosed by the Roman Pontiffs from the bond of his oath" (Extra, De Jurejur., cap. Verum in ea quaest., etc.). Therefore an oath is not always binding. Obj. 4: Furth
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   824   825   826   827   828   829   830   831   832   833   834   835   836   837   838   839   840   841   842   843   844   845   846   847   848  
849   850   851   852   853   854   855   856   857   858   859   860   861   862   863   864   865   866   867   868   869   870   871   872   873   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

binding

 

virtue

 

assertion

 

Therefore

 

creatures

 

contrary

 
Further
 

swearing

 
person
 

blasphemy


Objection

 
worship
 
health
 
employed
 

ARTICLE

 
future
 

SEVENTH

 
verified
 

mentioned

 

Binding


confirm
 

Whether

 

loosed

 

promise

 

virtuous

 

action

 

compelled

 

Pontiffs

 
quaest
 

Jurejur


desist

 

Corinth

 

stated

 

instance

 

commit

 

obstacle

 

thereto

 

fulfil

 
forbade
 
execute

princes
 

appointed

 
angels
 
worshipped
 

reverence

 
Jerome
 

justice

 

witness

 

Apostle

 
pledged