FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   129   130   131   132   133   134   135   136   137   138   >>  
to his absolute individualism has permitted himself to make concessions to Socialism, which are in flagrant contradiction with his announced intention and to the whole trend of his book, ends indeed by confessing that "if the new socialists were to preach collectivism _solely within the sphere of agricultural industry_, it would at least be possible to discuss it, since one would not be confronted at the outset by an absurdity, as is the case in attempting to discuss universal collectivism. This is not equivalent to saying that agricultural collectivism[97] would be _easily_ put into practice." That is to say that there is room for compromises and that a mitigated collectivism would not be in contradiction with all the laws of science, a contradiction which it seems his entire argument was intended to establish; for M. Garofalo confines himself to remarking that the realization of collectivism in land would not be _easy_--a fact that no socialist has ever disputed. There is no need for me to point out once more how this method of combating socialism, on the part of M. Garofalo, resemble that which the classical criminologists employed against the positivist school, when, after so many sweeping denials of our teachings, they came to admit that, nevertheless, some of our inductions, for example, the anthropological classification of criminals, might well be applied ... on a reduced scale, in the administration of jails and penitentiaries, but never in the provisions of the criminal law! During many years, as a defender of the positivist school of criminology, I have had personal experience of the inevitable phases that must be passed through by a scientific truth before its final triumph--the conspiracy of silence; the attempt to smother the new idea with ridicule; then, in consequence of the resistance to these artifices of reactionary conservatism, the new ideas are misrepresented, through ignorance or to facilitate assaults upon them, and at last they are partially admitted and that is the beginning of the final triumph. So that, knowing these phases of the natural evolution of every new idea, now when, for the second time, instead of resting upon the laurels of my first scientific victories, I have wished to fight for a second and more radical heresy; this time the victory appears to me more certain, since my opponents and my former companions in arms again call into use against it the same artifices of reacti
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   129   130   131   132   133   134   135   136   137   138   >>  



Top keywords:

collectivism

 

contradiction

 

discuss

 

phases

 

agricultural

 

triumph

 

Garofalo

 
school
 

artifices

 

scientific


positivist
 

inevitable

 

passed

 

criminals

 
reduced
 
applied
 

administration

 

penitentiaries

 

provisions

 

criminal


personal

 

criminology

 

defender

 

During

 
experience
 

wished

 

victories

 
radical
 

heresy

 

laurels


resting

 

victory

 

appears

 

reacti

 

opponents

 

companions

 

evolution

 

natural

 
resistance
 

reactionary


conservatism

 

consequence

 

silence

 

attempt

 

smother

 

ridicule

 

misrepresented

 

ignorance

 
admitted
 

beginning