FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   106   107   108   109   110   111   112   113   114   115   116   117   118   119   120   121   122   123   124   125   126   127   128   129   130  
131   132   133   134   135   136   137   >>  
because it involves the impossible conception of infinite past-time, he is logically bound by accepting one horn of the dilemma, to admit the conception of self-existence into the realm of the Knowable, or by choosing the other, to transfer his "Indestructibility," his "possibility of exact Science" into the realm of the Unknowable! In either event, we place an ultimate religious idea and a scientific conception whose denial he admits to be the annihilation of exact Science, upon the same footing, and so reduce the distinguishing characteristic which he has set up to differentiate the Knowable from the Unknowable, to zero. Second. We come now to the statement of some of the consequences which follow from Mr. Spencer's view--already explained--as to how the higher warrant, by which we know the Indestructibility of Matter to be an axiom, a self-evident truth, originated. In his chapter upon "Ultimate Scientific Ideas" he says that Space and Time are "wholly incomprehensible," and that "Matter ... in its ultimate nature, is as absolutely incomprehensible as Space and Time." He affirms, as pointed out, that no experimental verification is possible without assuming what we set out to prove. If the chemical balance cannot demonstrate this truth, how, then, can we know it? It is, we are told, an _a priori_ or necessary truth which arises in our consciousness through the "cognitions that have been rendered organic by immense accumulations of experiences, received partly by the individual, but mainly by all ancestral individuals whose nervous systems" we inherit. This is Mr. Spencer's answer. This commits us to the absurdity, that the truth of the doctrine of the Indestructibility of Matter has come to be accepted as axiomatic by the repetition of cognitions of an inconceivable "absolute uniformity" of things, by an indefinite series of ancestors, in the face of the fact that the present development of Science does not _now_ permit us, with the aid of all its apparatus, to receive a single logically valid cognition from the same phenomenal world which supplied all the others; _ergo_, add together a sufficient number of cognitions of the inconceivable, and you arrive at an axiomatic truth! To lift a ton weight, apply a vast number of forces of one ounce intensity, acting _successively_ in time, and the thing is done! Mr. Spencer cannot point out the characteristics which separate those inconceivable things and qualities which
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   106   107   108   109   110   111   112   113   114   115   116   117   118   119   120   121   122   123   124   125   126   127   128   129   130  
131   132   133   134   135   136   137   >>  



Top keywords:

Science

 

Indestructibility

 
cognitions
 

inconceivable

 

Spencer

 
Matter
 

conception

 
number
 
incomprehensible
 

axiomatic


Unknowable
 

things

 

Knowable

 

logically

 

ultimate

 

uniformity

 

repetition

 

absolute

 

doctrine

 
characteristics

separate
 

accepted

 

inherit

 
accumulations
 
experiences
 

received

 

partly

 
immense
 

organic

 

qualities


rendered
 

individual

 

indefinite

 
answer
 

commits

 

systems

 

nervous

 

ancestral

 

individuals

 
absurdity

sufficient

 
acting
 

intensity

 
successively
 
arrive
 

forces

 
weight
 

supplied

 

development

 
present