remark that madness has
pleasures unknown to the sane.

"Thou art, thou art alone,
A pure, pure being, but the God on high
Is with thee ever as thou goest by."

Julio watches again beside the Dead, till morning comes, bringing

"A murmur far and far, of those that stirred
Within the great encampment of the sea."

The tide sweeps the mad and the dead down the shores. "He perished in a
dream." As for the Hermit, he buried them, not knowing who they were,
but on a later day found and recognised the golden cross of Agathe,

"For long ago he gave that blessed cross
To his fair girl, and knew the relic still."

So the Hermit died of remorse, and one cannot say, with Walton, "and I
hope the reader is sorry."

The "other poems" are vague memories of Shelley, or anticipations of Poe.
One of them is curiously styled "Her, a Statue," and contains a passage
that reminds us of a rubaiyat of Omar's,

"She might see
A love-wing'd Seraph glide in glory by,
Striking the tent of its mortality.

"But that is but a tent wherein may rest
A Sultan to the realm of Death addrest;
The Sultan rises, and the dark Ferrash
Strikes, and prepares it for another guest."

Most akin to Poe is the "Hymn to Orion,"

"Dost thou, in thy vigil, hail
Arcturus on his chariot pale,
Leading him with a fiery flight--
Over the hollow hill of night?"

This, then, is a hasty sketch, and incomplete, of a book which, perhaps,
is only a curiosity, but which, I venture to think, gave promise of a
poet. Where is the lad of twenty who has written as well to-day--nay,
where is the mature person of forty? There was a wind of poetry abroad
in 1830, blowing over the barricades of Paris, breathing by the sedges of
Cam, stirring the heather on the hills of Yarrow. Hugo, Mr. Browning,
Lord Tennyson, caught the breeze in their sails, and were borne adown the
Tigris of romance. But the breath that stirred the loch where Tom
Stoddart lay and mused in his boat, soon became to him merely the curl on
the waters of lone St. Mary's or Loch Skene, and he began casting over
the great uneducated trout of a happier time, forgetful of the Muse. He
wrote another piece, with a sonorous and delightful title, "Ajalon of the
Winds." Where is "Ajalon of the Winds"? Miss Stoddart knows nothing of
it, but I fancy that the thrice-loathed Betty could have told a tale.

MALIM CONVIVIS QVAM PLACVISSE COQVIS