st not be supposed that these thoughts were lightly entertained, nor
may we imagine that they gave no distress to those who sincerely
believed that they were bound to accept what seemed to be their
inevitable consequences. To quote again from the _Candid Examination_
of Romanes, we may take it that he was speaking for many others when he
said, "Forasmuch as I am far from being able to agree with those who
affirm {36} that the twilight doctrine of the new faith is a desirable
substitute for the waning splendour of 'the old,' I am not ashamed to
confess that, with this virtual negation of God, the universe to me has
lost its soul of loveliness; and although, from henceforth the precept
'to work while it is day' will doubtless but gain an intensified force
from the terribly intensified meaning of the words 'that the night
cometh when no man can work,' yet when at times I think, as think at
times I must, of the appalling contrast between the hallowed glory of
that creed which once was mine, and the lonely mystery of existence as
now I find it--at such times I shall ever feel it impossible to avoid
the sharpest pang of which my nature is susceptible."
[1] _Logic_, Chap. V.
[2] _The Riddle of the Universe_, Chaps. XIV, XV.
[3] Chap. XII.
[4] _Fragments of Science_, p. 222.
[5] _First Principles_, i., pp. 33-39.
[6] _Essays_, Vol. III., pp. 246, f.
[7] In an essay written before 1889.
[8] _A Candid Examination of Theism_ (1876), pp. 171, f.
[9] _Nineteenth Century_, February, 1888.
{37}
CHAPTER IV
THE COUNTER-ARGUMENTS
It must not be imagined that all the arguments were on one side. Far
from it. The defenders of the old faith were many, and not the least
able of them were drawn from the ranks of the men of science. The list
of scientific leaders who avowedly ranged themselves on the Christian
side, if it were made out, would be a long one. It would include
distinguished names such as those of Faraday, Joule, the Duke of
Argyll, Lord Kelvin, Stokes, Tait, Adams, Clerk Maxwell, Salmon,
Cayley, and Pasteur. And others would have to be added who, after
contending for a while as materialists or agnostics, ultimately changed
their attitude and joined the supporters of Theism. Haeckel frankly
admitted that there were such defaulters from his cause in Germany,
giving the names of "two of the most famous of living scientists, R.
Virchow and E. Du Bois Raymond," amongst others. On the othe
|