FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   >>  
ci and Roberts. _Sterilization._--Brief mention must be made of _sterilization_--an operation whereby further pregnancy is prevented--which has been put forward by certain witnesses as a method of preventing abortion. Just as therapeutic abortion is, in certain cases, legitimately performed by medical practitioners, so has the operation of sterilization a recognized place in medical treatment of exceptional cases in which a woman's life is likely to be endangered or her health gravely impaired by further pregnancy. It can, indeed, be reasonably argued that in such cases sterilization is very definitely to be preferred to the very unsatisfactory alternative of repeated therapeutic abortion. Nevertheless, any general extension of this practice would, in the opinion of the Committee, be open to serious abuse. The Committee sees a tendency in some quarters to extend the indications for this operation far beyond the bounds of generally accepted medical opinion. The attitude of the Committee towards this matter is therefore the same as towards more specific legalization of therapeutic abortion. _The Prosecution of the Criminal Abortionist._--A very disquieting aspect of this problem is the relative immunity of the criminal abortionist from punishment. Conviction for the crime is rare, even in cases where guilt appears to be proved beyond all reasonable doubt. The Committee has sought to discover the reasons for the failure to obtain conviction. It is apparent that the police authorities are faced with many difficulties. In the first instance conviction is largely dependent on the evidence of a woman who, in the eyes of the law, is an accomplice to the offence, and corroboration of her evidence may be demanded. It has been suggested by certain witnesses that, if the woman were legally exempt from penalty, there would be less reticence about giving evidence and a greater fear on the part of the abortionist. On the other hand, it has been stated to the Committee that where such an indemnity is actually given, this very fact operates against conviction. The Commissioner of Police gave information that-- "Juries are loth to convict in such cases and appear to be impressed by the argument usually advanced by counsel for the defence that, as it was at the solicitation of the woman that the offence was convicted, she is the principal offender, and they adopt the view that unless she al
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   >>  



Top keywords:
Committee
 

abortion

 

therapeutic

 

conviction

 

medical

 

operation

 
evidence
 

sterilization

 

offence

 

opinion


abortionist

 

witnesses

 

pregnancy

 

principal

 
instance
 

largely

 

dependent

 

offender

 

accomplice

 

demanded


suggested
 

convicted

 

corroboration

 
reasons
 
failure
 

obtain

 

discover

 

reasonable

 

sought

 

difficulties


apparent

 

police

 

authorities

 

legally

 

operates

 

stated

 

indemnity

 
argument
 

Juries

 

information


Commissioner

 

impressed

 
Police
 
advanced
 

counsel

 

reticence

 
solicitation
 

convict

 
exempt
 

penalty