FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   445   446   447   448   449   450   451   452   453   454   455   456   457   458   459   460   461   462   463   464   465   466   467   468   469  
470   471   472   473   474   475   476   477   478   479   480   481   482   483   484   485   486   487   488   489   490   491   492   493   494   >>   >|  
Luke 4:13, the devil departed from Christ "for a time, because, later on, he returned, not to tempt Him, but to assail Him openly"--namely, at the time of His Passion. Nevertheless, He seemed in this later assault to tempt Christ to dejection and hatred of His neighbor; just as in the desert he had tempted Him to gluttonous pleasure and idolatrous contempt of God. _______________________ FOURTH ARTICLE [III, Q. 41, Art. 4] Whether the Mode and Order of the Temptation Were Becoming? Objection 1: It would seem that the mode and order of the temptation were unbecoming. For the devil tempts in order to induce us to sin. But if Christ had assuaged His bodily hunger by changing the stones into bread, He would not have sinned; just as neither did He sin when He multiplied the loaves, which was no less a miracle, in order to succor the hungry crowd. Therefore it seems that this was nowise a temptation. Obj. 2: Further, a counselor is inconsistent if he persuades the contrary to what he intends. But when the devil set Christ on a pinnacle of the Temple, he purposed to tempt Him to pride or vainglory. Therefore it was inconsistent to urge Him to cast Himself thence: for this would be contrary to pride or vainglory, which always seeks to rise. Obj. 3: Further, one temptation should lead to one sin. But in the temptation on the mountain he counseled two sins--namely, covetousness and idolatry. Therefore the mode of the temptation was unfitting. Obj. 4: Further, temptations are ordained to sin. But there are seven deadly sins, as we have stated in the Second Part (I-II, Q. 84, A. 4). But the tempter only deals with three, viz. gluttony, vainglory, and covetousness. Therefore the temptation seems to have been incomplete. Obj. 5: Further, after overcoming all the vices, man is still tempted to pride or vainglory: since pride "worms itself in stealthily, and destroys even good works," as Augustine says (Ep. ccxi). Therefore Matthew unfittingly gives the last place to the temptation to covetousness on the mountain, and the second place to the temptation to vainglory in the Temple, especially since Luke puts them in the reverse order. Obj. 6: Further, Jerome says on Matt. 4:4 that "Christ purposed to overcome the devil by humility, not by might." Therefore He should not have repulsed him with a haughty rebuke, saying: "Begone, Satan." Obj. 7: Further, the gospel narrative seems to be false. For it seems impossible
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   445   446   447   448   449   450   451   452   453   454   455   456   457   458   459   460   461   462   463   464   465   466   467   468   469  
470   471   472   473   474   475   476   477   478   479   480   481   482   483   484   485   486   487   488   489   490   491   492   493   494   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

temptation

 
Therefore
 
Further
 

vainglory

 

Christ

 

covetousness

 

mountain

 

Temple

 

inconsistent

 

purposed


contrary

 
tempted
 

tempter

 
ordained
 
counseled
 

unfitting

 

idolatry

 

temptations

 

stated

 

Second


narrative

 

gospel

 

deadly

 

impossible

 

unfittingly

 
Matthew
 

Augustine

 

overcome

 

repulsed

 
humility

Jerome

 

reverse

 

Begone

 

overcoming

 
incomplete
 

gluttony

 

rebuke

 
stealthily
 

haughty

 

destroys


nowise
 

ARTICLE

 

FOURTH

 

idolatrous

 

contempt

 

Whether

 

Objection

 

Becoming

 

Temptation

 
pleasure