FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   >>  
to the credit of recent Anthropometry. A brief glance at the strange changes of opinion in the latter field during the last three decades, in spite of all its boasted figures, shows how little ground it has to throw stones. Serious students, such as Wallace and Dall, whose critical ability in Zoomorphology no one can deny, and who do not rest content with a few skulls of doubtful _provenance_, gathered a la Hagenbeck, have come to a wholly negative view of the value of Craniometry."--Dr. Otto Stoll, _Maya-Sprachen der Pokom-Gruppe_, I, vii, ix. [43-*] Our present day speculators never seem to think for a moment that these things may conceal, _and thereby preserve_, some real meaning, or be more than nonsense. The theory of mythological interpretation pushed to such extremes as in the "animistic" _explanations_ of Weber, Keightley, and others, and not absent from the writings of some Americanists (namely, that it was all nothing but ridiculous or concocted fancy, taken soberly) is bad enough, and argues little breadth or insight, when applied to the myths of a single people, considered alone. Applied to comparative mythology, in the state of things today, it is simply impossible. The plain fact is, that such identities as these must indicate one of two things: a common tradition, locally modified by circumstances; or a _fact in nature_ or _history_, symbolically expressed in different ways according to the times and modes. And it most probably indicates both of these. It is indeed hard to account for the extent, and the weight given to some of these "myths," now that we are coming to a better appreciation of the scope and greatness of ancient civilizations--everywhere--except they do correspond to actual _facts_ in nature and history. And it might be worth our while to get at some of these. [45-*] We might just as well acknowledge, once for all, that in spite of its present-day currency in England and America, and its pre-emption of the field of "science for the people," the theory of man's physical and mental descent from the anthropoids, is not only _not proved_, but is vehemently denied by an equally able and scientific, and withal more logical, body of researchers than those who form its supporters. To _fabricate_ a missing link in a chain (or even, as with Haeckel, several links), whose only authority is acknowledged to be its necessity in order to complete the evidence for the theory, and then to declare the t
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   >>  



Top keywords:
theory
 

things

 

people

 

present

 

history

 

nature

 
weight
 
extent
 
coming
 

greatness


ancient

 

account

 

appreciation

 
tradition
 

common

 

locally

 

modified

 

circumstances

 

impossible

 

simply


identities

 

symbolically

 

expressed

 

civilizations

 
supporters
 

missing

 

fabricate

 

researchers

 
equally
 

scientific


logical

 

withal

 
complete
 

evidence

 
declare
 

necessity

 

acknowledged

 

Haeckel

 
authority
 

denied


vehemently
 
correspond
 

actual

 

acknowledge

 

physical

 

mental

 
descent
 

proved

 

anthropoids

 

science