FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   >>  
ut a private individual and a plain man." According to Hartman, "A. X. N." p. 350, "ridicule detorquet Hesiodeum": {outos men panaristos os auto panta noese esthlos d' au kakeinos os eu eiponti pithetai}. (7) Al. "in true sophistic style." The writer seems to say: "I lack subtlety of expression (nor is that at all my object); what I do aim at is to trace with some exactness, to present with the lucidity appropriate to them, certain thoughts demanded by persons well educated in the school of virtue." Nor am I singular in thus reproaching the modern type of sophist (not the true philosopher, be it understood); it is a general reproach that the wisdom he professes consists in word-subtleties, not in ideas. (8) Certainly it does not escape my notice that an orderly sequence of ideas adds beauty to the composition: (9) I mean it will be easy to find fault with what is written incorrectly. (10) Nevertheless, I warrant it is written in this fashion with an eye to rectitude, to make the reader wise and good, not more sophistical. For I would wish my writings not to seem but rather to be useful. I would have them stand the test of ages in their blamelessness. (11) (8) {onomasi}, "in names"; {noemasi}, "thoughts and ideas." (9) Or, "I am alive to the advantage to be got from methodic, orderly expression artistically and morally." (10) This passage, since H. Estienne (Stephanus) first wrote against it "huic loco meae conjecturae succumbunt," has been a puzzle to all commentators. The words run: {ou lanthanei de me oti kalos kai exes gegraphthai} ({gegraptai} in the margin of one MS.) {radion gar estai autois takhu me orthos mempsasthai' kaitoi gegraptai ge outos k.t.l.} For {takhu me orthos} (1) {takhu ti me orthos}, (2) {to} (or {ta}) {me orthos}, have been suggested. It is not clear whether {autois} = {tois sophistais} (e.g. "it will be easy for these people to lay a finger at once on blots, however unfairly"), or = {tois suggrammasi} (sc. my(?) compositions; so {auta}, S. 7 below, {ou gar dokein auta boulomai k.t.l.}) (e.g. "since it will be easy offhand to find fault with them incorrectly") (or if {ta me orthos}, "what is incorrect in them"). I append the three translations of Gail, Lenz, and Talbot. "Je sais combien il est avantageux de presenter des ouvrages methodiquement ecrits; aussi par le meme sera-t-il plus facile de p
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   >>  



Top keywords:

orthos

 
thoughts
 

written

 

incorrectly

 

gegraptai

 

orderly

 
autois
 

expression

 

radion

 

commentators


puzzle

 

Estienne

 

morally

 
passage
 
Stephanus
 

succumbunt

 

artistically

 

methodic

 

lanthanei

 

margin


gegraphthai
 

conjecturae

 
Talbot
 

combien

 
translations
 
offhand
 

incorrect

 

append

 

avantageux

 
facile

presenter
 
ouvrages
 
methodiquement
 
ecrits
 

boulomai

 

dokein

 

sophistais

 

suggested

 

kaitoi

 
people

compositions

 

suggrammasi

 

unfairly

 
finger
 

mempsasthai

 

sophistical

 

object

 
subtlety
 

sophistic

 

writer