FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   480   481   482   483   484   485   486   487   488   489   490   491   492   493   494   495   496   497   498   499   500   501   502   >>  
do not observe that the Lord experiences pleasure, pain, &c. caused by the pradhana. If the analogy between the pradhana and the bodily organs were a complete one, it would follow that the Lord is affected by pleasure and pain no less than the transmigrating souls are. Or else the two preceding Sutras may be explained in a different way. Ordinary experience teaches us that kings, who are the rulers of countries, are never without some material abode, i.e. a body; hence, if we wish to infer the existence of a general Lord from the analogy of earthly rulers, we must ascribe to him also some kind of body to serve as the substratum of his organs. But such a body cannot be ascribed to the Lord, since all bodies exist only subsequently to the creation, not previously to it. The Lord, therefore, is not able to act because devoid of a material substratum; for experience teaches us that action requires a material substrate.--Let us then arbitrarily assume that the Lord possesses some kind of body serving as a substratum for his organs (even previously to creation).--This assumption also will not do; for if the Lord has a body he is subject to the sensations of ordinary transmigratory souls, and thus no longer is the Lord. 41. And (there would follow from that doctrine) either finite duration or absence of omniscience (on the Lord's part). The hypothesis of the argumentative philosophers is invalid, for the following reason also.--They teach that the Lord is omniscient and of infinite duration, and likewise that the pradhana, as well as the individual souls, is of infinite duration. Now, the omniscient Lord either defines the measure of the pradhana, the souls, and himself, or does not define it. Both alternatives subvert the doctrine under discussion. For, on the former alternative, the pradhana, the souls, and the Lord, being all of them of definite measure, must necessarily be of finite duration; since ordinary experience teaches that all things of definite extent, such as jars and the like, at some time cease to exist. The numerical measure of pradhana, souls, and Lord is defined by their constituting a triad, and the individual measure of each of them must likewise be considered as defined by the Lord (because he is omniscient). The number of the souls is a high one[418]. From among this limited number of souls some obtain release from the sa/m/sara, that means their sa/m/sara comes to an end, and their subjection to the
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   480   481   482   483   484   485   486   487   488   489   490   491   492   493   494   495   496   497   498   499   500   501   502   >>  



Top keywords:

pradhana

 

measure

 

duration

 

omniscient

 

material

 

substratum

 
experience
 
organs
 

teaches

 

creation


individual

 
previously
 

definite

 

infinite

 
likewise
 

rulers

 

analogy

 
finite
 

doctrine

 

pleasure


ordinary

 

defined

 

follow

 
number
 

invalid

 
hypothesis
 

argumentative

 

absence

 

omniscience

 

philosophers


reason

 

defines

 

necessarily

 

considered

 

constituting

 

limited

 

subjection

 

obtain

 

release

 

numerical


discussion
 

subvert

 

alternatives

 

alternative

 

extent

 

things

 

define

 

Ordinary

 

explained

 

countries