ery acute piece, suggested by the
theme, which was printed in 1790. _Oeuv._ v. 343.
To illustrate the common fact of certain currents of thought being in
the air at given times, we may mention that in 1770 was published the
posthumous work of another Frenchman, Chesneau du Marsais (1676-1756)
entitled:--'_Essai sur les Prejuges; ou de l'influence des Opinions sur
les Moeurs et sur le Bonheur des Hommes_.' The principal prejudices to
which he refers are classed under Antiquity--Ancestry--Native
Country--Religion--Respect for Wealth. Some of the reasoning is almost
verbally identical with Condorcet's. For an account of Du Marsais, see
D'Alembert, _Oeuv._ iii 481.]
[Footnote 9: _Oeuv._ v. 354.]
[Footnote 10: Mill's _Three Essays on Religion_, p.73. I have offered
some criticisms on the whole passage in _Critical Miscellanies, Second
Series_, pp. 300-304.]
[Footnote 11: 'Enfin, supposons pour un instant que le dogme de l'autre
vie soit de quelqu'utilite, et qu'il retienne vraiment un petit nombre
d'individus, qu'est-ce que ces foibles avantages compares a la foule de
maux que l'on en voir decouler? Contre un homme timide que cette idee
contient, il en est des millions qu'elle ne peut contenir; il en des
millions qu'elle rend insenses, farouches, fanatiques, inutiles et
mechants; il en est des millions qu'elle detourne de leurs devoirs
envers la societe; il en est une infinite qu'elle afflige et qu'elle
trouble, sans aucun bien reel pour leurs associes.--_Systeme de la
Nature_, i. xiii.]
[Footnote 12: Sir J.F. Stephen's _Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity_,
2d. ed., p. 19, _note_.]
CHAPTER III.
INTELLECTUAL RESPONSIBILITY AND THE POLITICAL SPIRIT.
We have been considering the position of those who would fain divide the
community into two great castes; the one of thoughtful and instructed
persons using their minds freely, but guarding their conclusions in
strict reserve; the other of the illiterate or unreflecting, who should
have certain opinions and practices taught them, not because they are
true or are really what their votaries are made to believe them to be,
but because the intellectual superiors of the community think the
inculcation of such a belief useful in all cases save their own. Nor is
this a mere theory. On the contrary, it is a fair description of an
existing state of things. We have the old _disciplina arcani_ among us
in as full force as in the primitive church, but with an all-impor
|