FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   338   339   340   341   342   343   344   345   346   347   348   349   350   351   352   353   354   355   356   357   358   359   360   361   362  
363   364   365   366   367   368   369   370   371   372   373   374   375   >>  
the choice of the elephant's foot for the parallel of the Doric pillar: I even thought of omitting, or rewriting, great part of the chapter, but determined at last to let it stand. I am striving to speak plain truths on many simple and trite subjects, and I hope, therefore, that much of what I say has been said before, and am quite willing to give up all claim to originality in any reasoning or assertion whatsoever, if any one cares to dispute it. I desire the reader to accept what I say, not as mine, but as the truth, which may be all the world's, if they look for it. If I remember rightly, Mr. Frank Howard promised at some discussion respecting the "Seven Lamps," reported in the "Builder," to pluck all my borrowed feathers off me; but I did not see the end of the discussion, and do not know to this day how many feathers I have left: at all events the elephant's foot must belong to Mr. Garbett, though, strictly speaking, neither he nor I can be quite justified in using it, for an elephant in reality stands on tiptoe; and this is by no means the expression of a Doric shaft. As, however, I have been obliged to speak of this treatise of Mr. Garbett's, and desire also to recommend it as of much interest and utility in its statements of fact, it is impossible for me to pass altogether without notice, as if unanswerable, several passages in which the writer has objected to views stated in the "Seven Lamps." I should at any rate have noticed the passage quoted above, (Chap. 30th,) which runs counter to the spirit of all I have ever written, though without referring to me; but the references to the "Seven Lamps" I should not have answered, unless I had desired, generally, to recommend the book, and partly also, because they may serve as examples of the kind of animadversion which the "Seven Lamps" had to sustain from architects, very generally; which examples being once answered, there will be little occasion for my referring in future to other criticisms of the kind. The first reference to the "Seven Lamps" is in the second page, where Mr. Garbett asks a question, "Why are not convenience and stability enough to constitute a fine building?"--which I should have answered shortly by asking another, "Why we have been made men, and not bees nor termites:" but Mr. Garbett has given a very pretty, though partial, answer to it himself, in his 4th to 9th pages,--an answer which I heartily beg the reader to consider. But, in page 12
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   338   339   340   341   342   343   344   345   346   347   348   349   350   351   352   353   354   355   356   357   358   359   360   361   362  
363   364   365   366   367   368   369   370   371   372   373   374   375   >>  



Top keywords:

Garbett

 

answered

 
elephant
 

recommend

 

reader

 
answer
 
referring
 
desire
 

generally

 

examples


feathers
 

discussion

 

quoted

 
passage
 
partly
 
stated
 
noticed
 

altogether

 

counter

 
written

objected

 

passages

 

references

 

spirit

 

writer

 
desired
 

notice

 

unanswerable

 

termites

 

building


shortly

 

pretty

 
partial
 

heartily

 

constitute

 

occasion

 

future

 
sustain
 

architects

 

criticisms


question

 

convenience

 

stability

 

reference

 

animadversion

 
originality
 
reasoning
 

assertion

 

whatsoever

 

remember